Singapore lager glidande medelvärde

Titta på Daryl Guppy på CNBC Asia Squawk Box Guppytraders är en internationell finansmarknadsutbildningsorganisation med kontor i Darwin, Singapore och Peking. Vi tillhandahåller oberoende utbildning, utbildning, analys och resurser till detaljhandels - och professionella finansmarknadshandlare som är involverade i aktier, CFDs, teckningsoptioner, derivat, terminer och råvaror sedan 1996. Vårt mål är att ge dig kvalitativ oberoende utbildning och professionell hjälp eftersom den finansiella marknaden känner inte igen eleven handlare. Personligen undertecknade kopior av Daryl Guppys böcker. Weekly Market Nyhetsbrev för australiensiska och asiatiska marknader. Weekly analys nyhetsbrev för Kina fastlandet marknaden. Omfattande oberoende internetresurser för handlare. Nationella och internationella handelsseminarier. Professionell certifierad ekonomisk utbildning för handlare. Kartläggning av produkter och träningsprodukter. IP licensiering och licensiering av Guppy utbildning leverans (fråga om detaljer). Analys till finansiella medier, inklusive CNBCAsia och Reuters. Gratis MetaStock formler och bokrecensioner. Workshops för företag med verksamhet i Kina. Många av resurserna på denna sida är gratis. Detta är hemmet för Guppy Multiple Moving Average-indikatorn, Count Back Line. Paraboliska trender. modern Darvas-stilhandel och andra proprietära handelsmetoder, utvecklad av grundare och regissör, ​​Daryl Guppy. Vem är Daryl Guppy Daryl Guppy visas regelbundet på CNBCAsia och är känd som quot The Chart Man quot. Han är en aktie - och derivathandlare och författare till böcker, inklusive aktiehandel, marknadshandelstaktik, ögonblickshandel, bättre aktiehandel, trendhandel och de kinesiska kinesiska finansmarknadens strategier för finansiella handlare. Daryl Guppy är en bidragsyter för finansiella tidskrifter och media, inklusive: Technical Analysis of Stocks and Commodities magazine. En veckomängd på CNBC Asiens webbplats En veckomängd i China Daily Active Trader. Din Trading Edge. Singapore och Malaysiens verksamhet varje vecka, TheEdge. W eekly på lager och Shanghai Security News i Kina. (Endast Mandarin) Kolla in det nya sortimentet av artiklar som täcker Forex Market, som vi tillhandahåller av Forex Traders-teamet: quotUSDJPY VALUTA PAIR TREND ANALYSE Kolla in denna intervju av Daryl på NDTV på amerikanska marknader: Se uppåtgående rörelse på 12.600 på kort sikt Några saker våra kunder har att säga: Detta kommer att vara mitt 4 år att prenumerera och jag gillar att säga hur mycket jag har haft och lärt mig att läsa ditt nyhetsbrev Daryl. Kundtjänst har också varit förstklassig. Guppytraders är stolta över att presentera sin GRATIS Metastock Formula Database. Sammanslagna av Daryl Guppy och oberoende handlare från hela världen. Alla har arbetat med Metastock och producerat dessa formler för dig. Du kan hitta den formel som låter dig dra nytta av marknaden. Klicka här för att gå till Free Guppy Metastock Formula Database och annan Metastock information. Guppytraders (ACN 089 941 560): 22 Hibernia Crescent, Brinkin, Darwin, Australien Kina Office: Rum B105-A17, No.14, Chaoyangmen Nandajie, Chaoyang District, Peking, Kina Singapore Office: 10 Anson Road 21-02 International Plaza, Singapore Ansvarsbegränsning: Din användning av denna webbplats är ett bekräftelse på att du har läst, förstått och godkänt villkoren nedan. Ingen ansvarsskyldighet accepterad. All data som är kopplad till den här webbplatsen är upphovsrättsliga till sina enskilda utgivare och vi avstår från ansvar för noggrannheten i den information de tillhandahåller. Detta är en utbildnings - och informationswebbplats, så att notering på denna webbplats ska inte tas som en godkännande av någon produkt eller tjänst. Guppytraders Pty Ltd (ACN 089 941 560) är inte en licensierad investeringsrådgivare. Information har samlats utan hänsyn till enskilda personers investeringsmål, ekonomiska situation och särskilda behov eftersom besökare kommer från olika bakgrunder, med olika mål och ekonomiska situationer. Information som lämnas har enbart en allmän kommentar och varken avser eller avser att vara specifik handelsrådgivning. Information bör inte betraktas som ett erbjudande eller enticement att köpa, sälja eller handla. Den här webbplatsen är inte avsedd att ersätta din licensierade finansiell konsult eller din börsmäklare. Du bör söka lämplig rådgivning från din mäklare eller licensierad investeringsrådgivare eller kontakta någon av de mäklare som listas på denna sida innan du vidtar några åtgärder. CopyrightTrademarks: orden Guppytraders, Guppytraders. Guppy Multiple Moving Average, och andra är skyddade av upphovsrätt och varumärken. Sittiderna tider upp 16 punkter idag till 3089 efter den starka amerikanska marknaden. Wall Street slog rekordhöjningar för en fjärde dag som Janet Yellen förstärkte uppfattningen att världens bästa ekonomi var i god hälsa, med att jobbsökningen förbättrade marknaden och inflationen på pricken. Yellen bekräftade att nästa räntehöjning kunde komma när som helst, vilket lämnar möjligheten att flytta på Feds 14-15 mars-möte. För Singapores marknad idag, idag hade banksektorn en försiktig session. En fertig OCBC rapporterade en sänkning i Q4-vinsten på tisdag och även på grund av de kommande DBS-resultaten på torsdag och UOBs på fredag. Marknaden har gått upp ganska länge, är korrigeringen snart Efter min mening är den övergripande marknaden just nu fortsatt hausse, med STI över 3000 poäng Jag tycker att det fortfarande är okej att stanna kvar på marknaden, en korrigering kommer att komma om STI börjar falla under 3000 punkter. När det gäller sektorerna ser vi några vinstmarginaler i de viktigaste sektorns banker under de senaste dagarna, CityDev, DBS, bryter 5 dagars låga. Men just nu om du tittar på Hongkongs börsnoterade kinesiska banklager verkar de mycket starkare . idag ICBC upp 2,8, Kinas bank 3.9 Bank of comm 3.9 3.9 Vilka sektorer eller lager ska investerarna titta just nu Just nu tittar vi på Lager som är uppåtgående, som råvaror, finansierings - och spelbranschen. Med vinsttagandet i banker och fastighetsbranschen kommer fonder att flöda i andra sektorer eller lager som inte har gynnats av Bullish-marknaden. Dessutom kan investerare också titta på några av de bestånd som diskuteras om att ta över avtalen. Finansbolag som Singapura Finance, Hong Leong Finance och Sing Investments amp Finansiera sig kraftigt efter att MAS slappna av sin regel. MAS kommer nu att tillåta utländsk övertagande av Finansbolag Gratis Kommande Seminarium - Vad är den starkaste sektorn för att vara i? 2017 Vad är den svagaste sektorn att stanna ut? Hur fånga Stora vinnande aktier konsekvent utan att sätta din portfölj på för stor risk. Vad är de vanliga misstag som investeraren gör som hindrar dem från att vinna på aktiemarknaden. Januari var en fantastisk månad för Singapore börsen, STI upp mer än 150 poäng som egendom och oljebestånd tar av. Vi ser också några av mitten och små keps lager har en bra körning. Tja, om du följer vårt tidigare inlägg. de spelade sig ganska bra också, Sunpower upp 46, Japfa Amp Jumbo up 13 och MM2 Asia up 9. Sunpower har körts sedan oktober förra året, i december var det vila och bara till Jan, priset började flytta i snabbare takt . Japfa var tyst även i november och december, om du har följt den här bloggen tillräckligt länge så kommer du att se att när vi först nämnde var det bara 69 cent och vi fortsätter att vara hausse eftersom det fortfarande är upptrend, den svåra delen av att plocka detta beståndet var att förbli hemskt med det trots att alla ringer det för högt. Återigen var Jumbo vår 2016 favoritstock, när den var omkring 0,48, tills nu är vi fortfarande hausse om det (så länge det inte faller under 0.70) andy-yew201605can-jumbo-fly-like-thaibev-4-point. html MM2 asia, största vinnare under de senaste 2 åren, sedan den första posten på denna hemsida har börsen redan mer än 200 gratis kommande seminarier - Vad är den starkaste sektorn för att vara i för 2017 Vad är den svagaste sektorn att stanna ut Hur man fånga stor vinnande lager konsekvent utan att lägga portföljen på för stor risk. Vad är de vanliga misstag som investeraren gör som hindrar dem från att vinna på aktiemarknaden. Varför var marknaderna blandade före införandet av U-S-presidenten Donald Trumps invigning på fredag. Marknaden var nere efter den amerikanska marknaden, då Dow Jones faller något med 0,3. USD-indexet sjönk som svar på kommentarerna från den amerikanska presidenten Donald Trump, att USD var alltför stark. De amerikanska bestånden mjukade igår kväll. Asiatiska marknader som handlas blandat med Hongkongaktierna går bra, Hang Seng index upp mer än 1, Singapore STI faller till låga 2990 och lyckas återhämta förlusterna för att stänga på 3000. Den totala marknaden var ganska oro över Donald trumps invigningen denna fredag , men vi har inte sett något stort överraskningsdrag än. Att väcka vår uppmärksamhet till Singapore är att företagets vinstsäsong växer upp i full gång. Vad du tar på detta tror jag med vinsten som kommer ut, marknaden blir mer spännande och förväntar sig också att ha mer volatilitet. Nästa vecka den 26 januari kommer vi att se Keppel Corps intäkter. med att priset stiger högre under de senaste 2 månaderna, kan det här säga att oljebeståndet återhämtar sig. Jag tror att vi kan se fram emot att se några av dessa oljelagers resultat. Singapores STI svävar runt de tre tusen psykologiska varumärkena. Är den lokala marknaden berättigad för en korrigering Under de senaste 2 månaderna var de flesta vinsterna på indexstocken beroende av banksektorn, men resten av den andra sektorn hade inte riktigt ett stort drag, sålunda om det finns en korrigering , jag skulle tro att bankerna förmodligen kommer att dra tillbaka något som det är i den överköpta regionen. Med amerikanska dollar försvagas igår kväll ser jag att en del av aktien började rally, varför STI skulle dra tillbaka under 3000 på grund av att bankerna hade lite dra tillbaka, kan en viss sektor spela in och flytta högre. Därför istället för att dra våra pengar ut ur marknaden skulle jag anpassa mig till annat starkare lager inom olje - eller livsmedelssektorn. Kommande ETF-seminarium - Begränsade platser, Registrera nu Om du inte gillar att missa vinsten när marknadsförflyttning eller du vill titta på att köpa hela sektorn istället för att köpa enskilda företag, kan ETF vara svaret för dig. I det här fallet kommer vi att lära oss mer om. Vad är Exchange Traded Fund, Hur det kan gynna dig Top 10 ETF du borde veta år 2017 Vilken typ av ETF bör du undvika Vad är den gynnsamma typen av Exchange Traded Fund för Retail Investor. Registrera här Många frågar när är kvartalsresultatet eller helårsresultatet som kommer ut för Global Logistic, DBS, Genting amp osv. Vintersäsongerna för Q4 2016 är här, vilket är Singapores aktiebolagslönekalender för (Q4 2016) Anteckningar: Hämtade från Bloomberg Alla amerikanska Tech-resultatdatum har anpassats till Singapore-datum Klicka här för våra senaste kommande seminarier Onsdagen den 4 januari 2017 Under senaste månaden ser vi bara bankbranschen rally, resten av aktien listad i SGX sov verkligen. Idag ser vi äntligen några åtgärder igen, det här fåtalet är de vinnare som vi nämnde 2016, nu verkar de som att hämta styrka igen. Bransch: Livsmedelsindustri: Industriell maskinutrustning - Kina Baserat företag Bransch: Filmproduktion Biografdrift För mer sektoranalys eller marknadsutsikter. Jag kommer att dela den på mitt gratis seminarium i lördag på SGX-auditoriet. Plats: SGX Auditorium Kommer banksektorn att dra nytta av den stigande räntan Kommer Bärmarknadens 10-åriga cykel att hända i år (som 1997, 2007, 2017) Kommer STI att flytta över 3000 poäng Vi kommer också att dela med vad Risk och Möjligheter 2017 Investerare måste notera Dont missa detta kan du registrera detta gratis seminarium på denna länk under 2016 var ett år med mycket osäkerhet och överraskning för Singapore börsen. Vi startade 2016 i ett panikläge, eftersom oljepriset kraschar under 27 och slutade 2016 med ett haussejt läge med dow jones som slår all tid högt. Oljepriset var mer än 100 från låga, en överraskningstävling efter Brexit och en oväntad rally efter Donald trump valdes. Övergripande prestanda DJI - upp 13,1 SampP-up 9,4 Nasdaq - upp 7,89 US råolja 26,55 per fat nederst i januari - till högst 55,44, sluta året runt 54 STI - up 0.23 nära 2880, högsta 2981, lägst 2529. Hang säng index - ner -1,87 Shanghai Composite Index - Down-12,52 Kuala Lumpur Composite Index (KLCI) ner 3.5 Vad vi kan se är att den mesta av den asiatiska marknaden inte går så bra, främst på grund av kapitalflödet till den amerikanska marknaden. STI handlades nära 2850 under hela året. Högst uppnådde var 2981 när banksektorn rallyt, lägst gick det 2554 när oljepriset handlades under 27 år. Kommer oljebeståndet att återhämta sig 2017 Oljepriset återhämtar sig som nämnts ovan, det flyttade från 27 till 55, som redan säger att det är uppenbarligen inte nedåtgående. Med OPEC och en annan producent enats om produktionsminskning kunde oljebeståndet vara en av höjdpunkten för 2017. År 2016 ser vi att oljematerialet faller till den lägsta punkten, Ezra amp Ezion var i september på 0,037 amp 0,210, det var under nyheterna om swiber default på obligationer kom ut. Nu är de 0,05 (upp35 från låg) amp 0,39 (upp 85 från låga) respektive. För mig är båda riskabla lager men Ezion verkar ge en bättre avkastning när det gäller storleken på de tidigare uppåtgående rörelserna. Vad sägs om Sembcorp Amp Keppel Corp Keppel och Sembcorp var volatila handel under första halvåret, mitt år var ganska i sidled. Bara i november börjar priset hoppa upp igen. Sammantaget verkar båda stocken lika i mönster men jag kommer att gynna Sembcorp Ind över Keppel Corp som Sembcorp Ind har bättre prestanda än konkurrel corp de senaste åren. Vidare är en del av konkurrelkorpsverksamheten också i Fastigheter, om ränta upp, fastighetssektorn kanske dyster. För mer sektoranalys eller marknadsutsikter. Jag kommer att dela den på mitt gratis seminarium i lördag på SGX-auditoriet. Plats: SGX Auditorium Kommer banksektorn att dra nytta av den stigande räntan Kommer Bärmarknadens 10-åriga cykel att hända i år (som 1997, 2007, 2017) Kommer STI att flytta över 3000 poäng Vi kommer också att dela med sig av vad Risk och Möjligheter 2017 Investerare måste notera Dont missa detta kan du registrera det här gratis seminariet på den här länken nedan När 2016 kommer till en stängning, är jag så tacksam för er alla, det ökade antalet läsare som fortsätter att troget besöka denna blogg, Jag har samlat för dig en höjdlista över våra översta artiklar från 2016 som du kanske har missat. Så om du är ny på bloggen eller om du inte har tid att fånga varje del av våra artiklar, hoppas jag att några av dessa kommer och fortfarande är användbara för ditt lärande i denna investeringsresa. Vänta en min. detta är viktigt Jag vill också påminna om du är någon som betalar skatt i Singapore, oavsett om du är singaporean, PR eller utlänning. Du kan spara några tusen av din betalningsskatt och använda dessa pengar för att investera, vilket ytterligare förbättrar din totala avkastning på investeringen. Läs mer på SRS på den här webbplatsen: Sgwealthseminarsrs Under tiden hoppas jag att du har en glädjande semestersäsong med dig kärlek och ser fram emot en fantastisk 2017 tisdag 6 december 2016 Förra året var december en svår månad som marknadsstart faller efter Federal Reserve Rate Hike med 25 punkter. Den gemensamma frågan för den här tiden är, kommer Fed höja kursen den här gången Kommer marknaden reagera på samma sätt som förra året Shenzhen Hong Kong-anslutningen startade detta den 5 december, för första gången är Kina öppet för att övervaka investerare att byta lager listade i Shenzhen utbyte genom stock connect. Vi ser att Kina-indexet flyttar högre under de senaste månaderna, ser fram emot vi ska se mer positiv rörelse, eftersom utländsk placeringsfond flyttar till Kina. Hur jag tycker att Singapore-aktier kommer att gå i december Just nu är det som händer i Singapore bankerna den enda sektorn som uppenbarligen är stark, det beror på att räntehöjningen från federal reserv i december, men den flesta andra sektorn är inte så haussefulla utom råvaror och spelbranschen. I december kommer bankstocken sannolikt att ha vinsttillväxt eftersom de nu är i mycket överköpt läge, för råvaror och spelbranschen är jag fortfarande bullish. Vad är min handelsstrategi? Min strategi är att hålla sig i lager, den är stark och det här börsen får inte vara i Singapore, det kan vara i Kina, Hong Kong, USA, Malaysia, Thailand. var som helst vi kan nå ut till. Justera min position till den starka räknaren, anledningen till att jag gör det här är att jag är väldigt sjuk att fastna i en position. Starkt lager i Singapore: GSH, QAF, Genting Sing, Wilmar, Golden Agri, Auric Pacific, Venture Strong Stock i Malaysia: Gkent, MKH, Pmetal, SuperLn, YongTai Starkt lager i Hong Kong: Galaxy Entertainment, ASM Pacific, Kina Mengniu, Chow Tai Fook. Det finns mycket mer att dela I vårt kommande seminarium kommer vi att prata om Time Tested Propitiatory Strategy för handel med aktier. Hur denna strategi kan tillämpas på vilken marknad världen över. Enkla steg för att välja de växande bestånden. Hur kan du göra sektoranalys för att hitta vad är Strongweak-sektorn nu Market outlook och individuell Singapore-lageranalys med hjälp av teknisk analys 8 december 2016, kinesiskt seminarium torsdag kl 19.00 - 22.00 (registrering börjar kl. 18.30) 9 december 2016, engelska seminarium fredag ​​kl 19.00 - 22.00 börjar kl. 18.30) Plats. 34-07, 10 Anson Road, International Plaza, Singapore 079903 Var medveten om den här Shenzhen Hong Kong-lageranslutningen (Första gången öppnar Kina för enskilda investerare att köpa Shenzhen Share) eftersom de flesta beklagade under Shanghai Hong Kong stock connect , vissa ånger om att inte veta det tidigare där Shanghai Index flytta från 2100 till 5178, den snabbaste och starkaste tjur jag någonsin har sett. Inte gå in när det går för brant, indexet faller senare från 5178 till 2650. Se diagrammet nedan, gör du det är högt eller lågt nu Är det en möjlighet Det är dags att lära sig om Kina marknaden 6531165281 Hur man investera i Hong Kong Kina lager (klicka på datumet nedan för att registrera) 65288 65289 Registrera: 2 dec 2016 (fredag) engelska Seminarium eller register: 9 dec 2016 (fredag) (A) När är Shenzhen Hong Kong-lager Connect start 65311 5 december 2016, måndag 0930hr Singapore timing. Kommer Shenzhen Stock Connect att ha positiv inverkan på Kinas aktiemarknad 65311 Med nuvarande marknadsperspektiv visar diagrammet ett positivt tecken, i början av året var marknaden helt livlös, nu blir det mer lovande som vi såg mest lager har stigit. Stor bank som Morgan Stanley höjer målet för Shanghai index till 4400 för 2017. Hur kan du komma igång 65311 För att få alla redo, har mitt team satt ett speciellt seminarium för att prata om detta ämne. I denna session lär du dig: Hur man börjar investera med Kina Dela Effekten av MSCI-inkludering för Kina Stocks Shenzhen Hong Kong Link - Vilket lager, ETF-amp Unit Trust att titta på Hur får man GRATIS Realtidspris för Hong Kong-amp Kina Aktier Var kan man läsa gratis forskningsrapport och aktierekommendation från finansanalytiker Saker att undvika vid handel med Kina Dela aktieanalys för aktieinnehav CFD-introduktion för Kina A-aktier Amp Hong Kong-aktier Eftersom efterfrågan på denna jämn är väldigt hög just nu föreslår jag att du registrera ett säte just nu innan det är full bok. Så fortsätt och klicka på länken nedan för att registrera dig nu. 65288 65289 Registrering: 2 dec 2016 (fredag) Engelska Registrera: 9 dec 2016 (fredag) Tid: 19:00 - 21:30 (Registrering börjar kl. 18.30) Avgift: Fri entréplats: Nivå 6. Presentationsrum, Raffles City Tower, 250 North Bridge Road, City Hall MRT (Exit A) Li Shufu, en miljarder och ordförande för en av China8217s mest framgångsrika privata bilföretag, förvärvade Volvo från Ford 2010. Hans företag heter Geely Automobile Holdings (0175.HK) som är listad i Hongkong Börsen har stigit upp stadigt. Baserat på vårt ART-handelssystem har köpssignalerna visat konsekvent lönsamma affärer. Nyligen finns det en köpsignal igen (se nedan diagram), kan vi titta noga. Geely Automobile Holdings Limited är ett Hong Kong-baserat företag som huvudsakligen är verksamt inom bilrelaterade företag, inklusive forskning, utveckling, tillverkning och försäljning av bilar och bilkomponenter. Bolaget driver bl. a. företag i Kina, Europa, Mellanöstern, Sydkorea och Afrika. Dina dotterbolag inkluderar Centurion Industries Limited, Value Century Group Limited, Geely International Limited, Zhejiang Fulin Guorun Automobile Parts Amp Components Co. Ltd och Linkstate Overseas Limited, bland andra. Geely har sedan 2010 ägit den svenska personbilsmaskinen Volvo Cars och taxibilar under London Taxi-varumärket. Leveransbilar säljs under varumärket Emerald. Vill du få mer frekventa Trading Ideas i din e-post eller SMS Öppna ett gratis handelskonto med oss ​​nu bit. ly1gegCv0. United Engineer stiger mer än 50 i år medan STI blir platt trots att fastighetsmarknaden är svag och United Engineer-aktiekursen fortfarande överträffar marknaden. Finansiell sammanfattning - lageranalys KORT: För de nio månader som slutade den 30 september 2016, minskade engagemanget för United Engineers Limited 49 till SP358.2M. Nettoresultatet före extraordinära poster minskade 18 till SP32.3M. Intäkterna speglar en minskning av efterfrågan på Companys produkter och tjänster på grund av ogynnsamma marknadsförhållanden. Nettoresultatet speglar också Distributionskostnaderna ökar med 12 till SP21,6M (kostnad), Finanskostnaderna ökar med 4 till SP27.9M (kostnad). En orsak till styrkan beror på att United Engineers vinster på försäljningen av UES UES Holdings och olika miljötekniska tillgångar i Kina ökade sin totala bottenlinje och steg 625 till 134,7m. En annan anledning skulle vara möjligheten att överta av Charoen Sirivadhanabhakdi, Thailands rikaste person, talet är fortfarande på väg. Investerare spekulerar också. Singapore Stock Outlook Seminar Hur man identifierar stora vinnande lager 25 november 2016, fredag, kl 19.00 - 22.00 (Registrering börjar kl. 18.30) Plats. 34-07, 10 Anson Road, International Plaza, Singapore 079903 Resultatet av USA: s presidentval överraskade marknader som republikansk kandidat Donald Trump valdes. Stora Asien-Stillahavsmarknaderna föll i stort sett med Nikkei 225 Stock Average tumling 5.4. Hongkongaktierna följde till en nedgång 2,2. Straits Time Index, efter att ha öppnat högre 17pts, en gång kasta 60 pts till botten vid 2760. Marknaden återhämtar sig till 30pts eller 1.1 till slutet vid 2789 efter Trump Victory tal ger investerare på att bygga upp nationen och lovar att göra ett bra jobb. De totala aktieindexen är pressade på grund av osäkerheten under röstberäkningen, jag tror att det här beror på panikförsäljning som liknar Brexit. Under den asiatiska handelstiden faller amerikanska dollarn dåligt mot yenen, men förlusterna har minimerats när marknaden lugnar ner efter att valresultatet är ute. Bara en vecka sedan. Jag nämnde att vi skulle få ut pengar från aktier och lägga i guld och Gold är starkt idag. Nu är det bra att flytta tillbaka till lager, jag tror att aktierna har tankat tillräckligt idag och med det nya ordförandeskapet som sprutar mer osäkerhetsfaktorer i den amerikanska ekonomin, kan Federal Reserve försena kurshöjningen i december. Om så är fallet kan REITS vara en bra sektor att investera för nu. Jag tittar på Keppel DC-reit, Capitacom Reit, Mapletree Com Reits den 10 november 2016, torsdag kl. 19.00-10.00. (Registrering börjar kl. 18.30) 18 november 2016, fredag, kl. 19.00-10.00. (Registreringen börjar kl. 6.30 pm) plats. 34-07, 10 Anson Road, International Plaza, Singapore 079903 Det har varit ett tag sedan jag senast postade på de lager jag tittar på som jag har varit hibernating i mer än en månad. Det är dags för mig att vara tillbaka för att tjäna samhället igen och delar min syn på marknaden. Under de senaste veckorna har vi det bästa örebeståndet sedan blumontiden, det här är en bra nyhet för alla investerare och handlare i Singapore som det säger till oss att marknaden inte är död ännu. Så länge stora pojkar kan tjäna pengar, kommer marknaden att ha möjligheter. Samma teori som varför du inte vill döda alla hajar i havet. Tidigare nämnde jag MM2 Asia i juli 2015, nu upp 300 Japfa i maj 2016 nu upp 30 Kina Aviation maj 2016 nu upp 40 Cityneon i juni 2016, nu är upp 35 Ovanstående aktier är fortfarande bra, om du fortfarande håller, grattis till dig. För mer information, kolla in det kostnadsfria seminariet nedanför platsen. 34-07, 10 Anson Road, International Plaza, Singapore 079903 Tja, kom tillbaka till Singapore övervakningslista över Uptrending lager nu andra än de som nämnts ovan. 1) HMI - Företaget är en vårdgivare med närvaro i Singapore, Malaysia och Indonesien. Kompanysegmenten inkluderar sjukhus och andra sjukvårdstjänster Hälso - och sjukvårdspedagogik och Investeringsinnehav. Bolaget äger och driver Mahkota Medical Center i Malacca och Regency Specialist Hospital i Iskandar Malaysia med en total bäddkapacitet på över 500 som tillhandahåller en serie medicinska och kirurgiska tjänster. För räkenskapsåret som slutade den 30 juni 2016 ökade intäkterna för Health Management International Ltd. 15 till RM397,8 miljoner. Nettoresultatet minskade 28 till RM19,9M. Intäkterna återspeglar sjukhus och andra sjukvårdstjänster ökade segmentet med 15 till RM388,2M, segmenthöjning inom hälso - och sjukvårdsutbildning och utbildning ökade med 14 till RM9,6M, Malaysia ökade segmentet med 15 till RM388,2M, Singapore ökade segmentet med 14 till RM9,6M. 2) SingMedical - Singapore Medical Group Limited är verksamt inom medicinsk klinik och tillhandahållande av allmänna sjukvårds - och investeringsinnehav. Bolaget verkar genom tre segment. Dess Hälsosegment består av generella oftalmologiska tjänster, såsom implanterbara kontaktlinser och kataraktkirurgiska ortopediska tjänster, inklusive behandlingar för onkologitjänster i samband med ledskador och broskskador, inklusive förebyggande, diagnos och behandling av obstetriska och gynekologiska tjänster för cancer, som tillgodoser wellness av kvinnliga otolaryngologiska tjänster dermatologitjänster och allmän medicin och hälsoskärmningstjänster. För de sex månader som slutade den 30 juni 2016 ökade Singapore Medical Group Ltd-intäkterna 34 till SP19.5M. Nettoresultatet uppgick till SP633K mot förlust av SP240K. Intäkterna återspeglar en ökning av efterfrågan på Companys produkter och tjänster på grund av gynnsamma marknadsförhållanden. 3) Yanlord Land - The Companys segmenten omfattar Fastighetsutveckling, Fastighetsinvestering m. fl. Dess fastighetsutvecklingssegment är inblandat i utveckling av bostads-, kommersiella och andra fastigheter. Dess fastighetsinvesteringssegment är inblandat i uthyrning av fastigheter för att generera hyresintäkter och att hämta från värdet på fastigheterna på lång sikt. Dess andra segment är inblandat i tillhandahållande av fastighetsförvaltning, tilläggstjänster, förskott köp av byggmaterial, investment holding och andra. För de sex månader som slutade den 30 juni 2016 ökade Yanlord Land Group Limited-intäkterna från RMB3.35B till RMB10.26B. Nettoresultatet ökade från RMB186.5M till RMB584.1M. Intäkterna återspeglar en ökning av efterfrågan på Companys produkter och tjänster på grund av gynnsamma marknadsförhållanden. Nettoresultatet gynnas av övrig rörelseinkomst ökning med 22 till RMB220,4M (intäkter). Singapore-marknaden var nere 7 poäng idag till 2807, den svaga känslan beror främst på USA: s presidentval 2016, som den beror på den 8 november, precis nästa tisdag. Den övergripande marknaden har varit en ganska stor räckvidd för de senaste månaderna för singapore marknaden och för Hong Kong och USA marknaden verkar det som om investerare tar vinst från bordet efter de senaste rallyerna, investerare är inte säkra vem som ska väljas och vad kommer hända efter valet och därmed sätta vinster i fickorna kan vara ett bra val den här veckan. Några vänner frågade om Starthub .. Starhub-resultatet är klart att nettoresultatet för Q3 minskar med 28 jämfört med förra året på grund av lägre vinst från sin verksamhet och även högre räntekostnader. Sammantaget är jag inte angelägen i någon av telcosektorerna, eftersom vi kan se att de är nedåtgående och också svagare än marknaden. M1 har fallit nära 50 sedan 2015, starhub faller ca 25, bland de 3 telco singtel är den starkaste genom att falla minst, bara 15 under de senaste 2 åren. Intressant räknare för den här veckan: OUE begränsade hänförliga vinstökningar till S107,6 miljoner i 3Q 2016 Ökning av intäkterna med mer än fyra gånger från S99,0 miljoner i 3Q 2015 till S419,1 miljoner. Jag ser att guldpriset kryper upp i takt med att amerikanska dollarn försvagas, det verkar som om investerarna kör för säkra hamnar före valet. Jag tror att vi kan titta på Gold Etf eller Gold miners under denna period av marknads osäkerhet. Mötesplats. 34-07, 10 Anson Road, International Plaza, Singapore 079903 Shenzhen-Hongkong Stock Connect (SZ-HK Stock Connect) lanseras i slutet av november. Även om det faktiska lanseringsdatumet inte meddelas ännu, sade Li Xiaojia, VD för Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX), att det är föredraget att starta SZ-HK Stock Connect på en måndag i slutet av november. Den 13 oktober 2016 höll HKEX och Shenzhen Stock Exchange (SZSE) en investors roadshow i Hong Kong, vilket signaliserar starten på de internationella investors roadshowsna för SZ-HK Stock Connect. Li Xiaojia. VD för HKEX, meddelade tillsammans med Wang Hong, VD för SZSE, att HKEX och SZSE kommer att genomföra ett tre veckors systemtest för handelslänken mellan 17 oktober 2016 och 9 november 2016 och är klar att slutföras i mitten November. Varför investerare övervakar noga Shenzhen Hong Kong Connect Kort översikt över SZ-HK Stock Connect De dagliga kvoterna för Hong Kong Stock Connect och Shenzhen Stock Connect är respektive CNY10.5Bn respektive CNY13Bn. SZ-HK Stock Connect har ingen aggregerad kvot vid den första lanseringen. SZ-HK Connect täcker cirka 880 aktier, som inkluderar beståndsdelarna i SZSE Component Index och SZSE Small-Midcap Innovation Index med marknadsvärde på mer än CNY6Bn och aktier noterade på SZSE som företagen har emitterat både A - och H-aktier. Hong Kong Stock Connect täcker beståndsdelarna av Hang Seng Composite LargeCap Index och Hang Seng Composite MidCap Index, beståndsdelar med marknadsvärde på mer än HKD5Bn i Hang Seng Composite SmallCap Index och aktier noterade på HKEX som företagen har utfärdat både A och H aktier. Inverkan på Hongkongaktier Hongkongaktierna är relativt undervärderade jämfört med Shenzhen-aktier, vilket framgår av Shenzhen A-aktierna har en genomsnittlig historisk PE-kvot på 40x medan Hongkong-aktierna har en genomsnittlig historisk PE-kvot på 11x. Kinesiska investerare förväntas använda den sydgående kanalen för att investera i Hongkongs aktier. Vi förväntar oss dock att endast MidCap och SmallCap-aktierna i Hong Kong kommer att dra nytta av SZ-HK Stock Connect, och effekten på stora index kommer att vara begränsad eftersom de har ingått i Shanghai-Hong Kong Stock Connect redan. For the first time, the stock connect expands to constituent stocks with HKD5Bn market capitalization of Hang Seng Composite SmallCap Index, whose valuation ratio implies the stocks are relatively undervalued in comparison with those listed on SZSE. Funds are expected to flow into the MidCap and SmallCap stocks in Hong Kong, and these stocks are expected to benefit from the stock connect programme. However, the primary participants of A Shares market are retail investors, who are highly sensitive to market rumours. Therefore, we expect the SmallCap and MidCap stocks in Hong Kong to be more volatile in the future. Source: PSPL (HK), HKSE, SZSE, SFC (HK) The following stocks are the AH shares. The final eligible stocks for SZ-HK Stock Connect will be announced by HKEX. The information previously on this page about military caning in Singapore has been removed to the Country files section. Judicial corporal punishment by caning is in widespread use for male offenders in Singapore, Malaysia and Brunei, three adjacent and closely linked members of the British Commonwealth in South-East Asia. This article is about judicial CP (JCP) and CP for infractions of prison rules. It does not include caning in the military or in boys reformatories, or the (much less severe) caning of boys at school, which is covered elsewhere on this website . Thousands of judicial canings are ordered each year. Men are caned for serious crimes and also for non-violent offences like illegal entry and vandalism. In some cases it is a mandatory punishment. These canings are very severe and are criticised by such organisations as Amnesty International. Caning in all three countries is administered across the bare seat. Contrary to popular myth, this is always done privately inside the prison. There has never been public JCP these countries. The prisoner is stripped naked and shackled by strong leather straps to a trestle or A-frame. In Singapore and Brunei he is held down in a bent-over position with his buttocks protruding. In Malaysia he stands upright at the A-frame to which he is tied. He is then punished by a well-built warder wielding a four-foot long length of flexible rattan which has been soaked in water. Left: Official demonstration of caning of a dummy in Singapore Right: Official demonstration of caning of a dummy in Malaysia Left: Official demonstration of caning of a dummy in Brunei THE HISTORY OF CANING IN SINGAPORE, MALAYSIA AND BRUNEI The penal legislation in what used to be British Malaya -- the peninsular part of present-day Malaysia, plus Singapore -- has its historical roots in the criminal laws of England and India. When the Straits Settlements, comprising the three predominantly Chinese-populated port cities of Singapore, Melaka (Malacca) and Penang (George Town), was formed as a British colony in 1826, the criminal law of England applied. Straits Settlements Penal Code Ordinance IV replaced the common law in 1871. It was based on the Indian Penal Code, enacted in 1860. Offences punishable by whipping in the Code were robbery, aggravated theft, house trespass or house breaking, assault with intent to outrage modesty, and a second or subsequent offence of rape or living on or trading in prostitution. This list of whipping offences was roughly similar to that of England and Wales at the time. The remainder of what is now Malaysia consisted of separate Moslem sultanates, nominally independent but increasingly under de facto British control. By the early part of the 20th century, these had coalesced into three groupings: the Federated Malay States (FMS), a fully-fledged British protectorate with a new federal capital at Kuala Lumpur this comprised the sultanates of Selangor, Perak, Pahang and Negri Sembilan the unfederated Malay states, a more diffuse (and not geographically contiguous) grouping of five states, four of which were ceded in 1909 by Siam (now Thailand), with a somewhat looser relationship with Britain and two states on the island of Borneo, British North Borneo (now Sabah) and Sarawak, nowadays together described as East Malaysia. A third Malay sultanate on Borneo, the small oil-rich state of Brunei, has, like Singapore, chosen to become independent rather than be part of the new post-1963 Malaysia. Given all these shifting legal and constitutional complexities, it is not clear exactly how, when or to what extent practice in judicial matters such as CP became unified across the whole territory. However, at least from the First World War onwards, the whole peninsula was in political terms regarded as British Malaya and for practical purposes was run as an entity, overseen by a Governor based in Singapore who reported to the Colonial Office in London. What is clear, anyway, is that the JCP regime as it developed was an outgrowth of British judicial custom and practice. It did not have anything to do with Islamic justice. The fact that much of the territory (except for the Straits Settlements) had a majority Moslem population was coincidental. During this period, the instrument used for CP was either a cat-o-nine tails or a rattan, and the triangles were of the usual pattern, and the flogging was on the buttock. The travel writer Bruce Lockhart, visiting Singapore in the early 1930s, was shown round the jail: Crossing from one block of buildings to another, we passed a narrow oblong strip of grass surrounded by high windowless walls. . There was an atmosphere of cloistered seclusion about the place. . And yet there was something uncanny and sinister about these high grey walls which shut out everything except the stretch of sky overhead. The plot is not an architects whim. It has its uses. Sometimes its walls resound with the dull, heavy sound of the lash and with the screams of prisoners. . Since the 1890s this plot has been used for floggings and hangings. (R. H. Bruce Lockhart, Return to Malaya . Putnam, London, 1936.) Most canings in prison are ordered by the courts for offences against the law, but the punishment can also be inflicted for infractions of prison discipline. In 1938 canings for breaches of the prison rules in the Straits Settlements were: 24 strokes - 2 sentences 20 strokes - 1 sentence 12 strokes - 9 sentences 8 strokes - 2 sentences 6 strokes - 8 sentences 4 strokes - 1 sentence For the last three years of the Second World War, the whole territory was under military occupation by Japan. It is not known to what extent, if at all, the ordinary machinery of justice functioned during this period. After the war, Britain resumed control on an interim basis with a view to granting independence. The old Straits Settlements colony was not revived. Instead, Singapore was made a separate colony, while a new Federation of Malaya based in KL comprised all the rest of the peninsula -- the former FMS and the former UMS plus Malacca and Penang. At this point the Singapore Penal Code retained its provisions for whipping, but they were not particularly frequently used. In 1949, 46 offenders (all adult men) were caned by order of the court, and 26 for prison offences. The 1948 Report of the Singapore Prison Enquiry Commission records the rules at that time for prison offences: For aggravated offences against prison discipline - - ordered by Superintendent: not exceeding 12 strokes with a rottan - ordered by Visiting Justices: not exceeding 24 strokes with a rottan - for Juveniles under 15 years, by Visiting Justices: not exceeding 6 strokes with a light rottan. Punishment with the rottan shall be inflicted on the buttocks of the offender. In the case of adults the rottan shall be not more than half an inch in diameter, while in the case of juveniles a light rottan shall be used. In 1953 there were 12 cases of caning for internal prison disciplinary reasons, and in 1954 only two (information from annual prison service reports). Mention is also still made of the possibility of the cat being used, but in practice it seems to have fallen out of use by this period. In 1955 the Criminal Justice (Punishment Amendment) Ordinance removed the cat-o-nine tails from the Singapore statute book, and thenceforth corporal punishment could be inflicted only with a rotan (or rottan or rattan -- these are simply different spellings of the Malay word for cane). At the same time, the power to award JCP was restricted to the High Court -- a move that was later reversed, for nowadays local and subordinate courts all have caning powers. In 1954 there had been a mere 7 canings ordered by the courts. In 1994 a letter from a former superintendent of Changi Prison during the British colonial period confirmed that canings were inflicted on the bare buttocks. He describes 6 or 12 strokes as the usual punishment, and says he never saw profuse bleeding, only severe bruising. This might suggest that the manner of infliction has become more severe over time. Corporal punishment as a judicial penalty was abolished in England, Wales and Scotland in 1948. and in India in 1955. In all parts of Malaya, however, as in Hong Kong, caning was retained. In Singapore, independent from British rule in 1965, the scope of JCP was increased by legislation on many occasions from 1966 onwards, providing for its use in a greater range of offences, often requiring its mandatory imposition, and on occasions increasing the minimum number of strokes. Since 1993 it has become mandatory for 42 crimes, and optional for a further 42 (see table below) and partly as a result (combined with rapid increases in population) its use has increased from a few dozen to thousands of sentences a year. The most recent extension of caning powers was in February 2008, when five new offences were added to the list. The earlier of these post-independence extensions of the scope of JCP were publicly justified, in part, as the official response to an alarming crime wave: armed robberies tripled between 1966 and 1971. Much of this was gang-related. It was a modern resurgence of an old difficulty: like the rest of the Chinese diaspora, Singapore had historically faced a serious gangsterism problem. The present regime claims, citing UN figures, that Singapore now has one of the lowest rates of violent crime in the world, even compared with famously tranquil places such as Denmark and Switzerland -- partly no doubt because the authorities have managed to make the island almost entirely gun-free (No death from killers bullet in Spore, Straits Times . 9 May 2000). The British colonial authorities had likewise used corporal punishment to deal with organised gang violence in the 1920s and 1930s. The Governor of the Straits Settlements wrote to the Colonial Office in London in October 1929 that the yearly influx of uneducated Chinese into Singapore has created a situation which can only be met by measures which might at first sight appear to be somewhat at variance with the accepted ideas of punishment at the present time. He enclosed a return showing that, excluding canings for prison discipline, 78 offenders had been whipped in 1928, mostly for armed robbery or -- an offence added to the list only in 1926 -- the possession of weapons. London seems to have found the figures rather excessive: the Secretary of State had said that the frequent resort to flogging as a punishment in the Colony appears to require some special justification, so the Governor also enclosed a letter from the Chief Justice, drawing attention to the exceptional prevalence of very brutal gang robberies, mostly committed by young lawless Chinese of the coolie class who immigrate . in a continuous stream every year . a continually renewed source of potential crime. The Chief Justices letter concluded: I am convinced that the power to whip is essential to the judiciary for dealing with the particular types of crime that are prevalent in Singapore. This view was echoed by the Deputy Public Prosecutor, Singapore, who observed that prison alone was no deterrent to this type of criminal: Men who live from hand to mouth and in uncomfortable surroundings . find prison life by comparison not unpleasant . only flogging would have any real and lasting effect. (Public Record Office, CO 27355413.) It is clear from these and other historical records that, except for the light rattan canings of juveniles for much less serious offences, the use of judicial CP was regarded by the British colonial authorities as appropriate only for crimes involving personal violence or the threat thereof. It is from this long-held policy stance that modern Singapore, Malaysia and Brunei have so radically departed. These are wide-ranging, particularly in Singapore. There are dozens of offences for which a man might be given the cane -- from serious violent crimes to some non-violent offences that might seem relatively minor in the West but are regarded as serious in Singapore, a highly authoritarian state where the importation and sale of chewing gum is an offence (though not a caneable one) and where people can be fined significant sums for dropping litter, smoking in public places, or failing to flush a public toilet after use. Malaysia is markedly less authoritarian at that trivial level, but its attitudes towards more serious crime and the use of corporal punishment are very similar. In particular, drugs offences and sexual offences frequently attract very heavy caning sentences in all three countries. To these severe canings for serious offences have been added, in recent years, in both Malaysia and Singapore, a very large number of much less severe canings of illegal immigrants. The number of offences for which caning may or must be inflicted has continued to increase in all three countries, and politicians from time to time float suggestions in the local press about yet further crimes to add to the list. In Malaysia over recent years, for instance, there have been calls for caning to be introduced for: The idea that criminals might be reformed was explicitly abandoned by some senior members of Singapores judiciary: former Chief Justice Yong Pung How said in 1996. Rehabilitation is something I have never understood . Compassion went out the window a long time ago. Now I just deliver justice. But in 2006 a new Chief Justice was appointed in Singapore, Chan Sek Keong, who was quoted by the Associated Press as wanting to give judges more room to give alternative punishments, with rehabilitation in mind. This emboldened the President of the Association of Criminal Lawyers to describe current practices as outdated, and he continued: Everything is jail, or jail plus caning. There must be alternative sentencing options like community service, or probation, or probation with a lot of strings attached to it. Singapore claims particular success in its war on drugs. In addition to implementing the death penalty for drug-traffickers (as Malaysia also does), in 1998 Singapore introduced a special scheme for non-trafficking drug addicts called the long-term imprisonment (LT) regime. This originally covered users of opiates such as morphine and heroin, but has since been extended to include synthetic drugs like Ketamine, Ecstasy and Subutex. Under the scheme, 4,500 addicts were jailed for up to seven years and given six strokes of the cane between 1998 and 2006. Less than 2 of these were caught taking drugs again, and these few were then jailed for up to a further 13 years, with up to 12 further strokes of the cane. (All out to nab the junkies, Today . Singapore, 7 September 2006). Caning in Singapore is mandatory for over 40 different offences. These include rape, robbery, possession of offensive weapons, vandalism, and the sale or import of fireworks and also for any drug-trafficking cases where for one reason or another the death penalty is not applied. (Offenders sentenced to death are not caned as well.) Possession of offensive weapons may likewise attract a caning sentence in Malaysia. Vandalism does not at present, though there have been suggestions that it should . In some cases a mandatory minimum number of strokes is required -- up to 15 for certain offences. Men who enter Singapore illegally or who overstay their visas by more than 90 days automatically receive a minimum of 3 strokes of the cane. This provision is aimed essentially at controlling foreign workers. Malaysia and Brunei have copied Singapore in this respect, and now have similar provisions, except that in Malaysia the minimum sentence is only one stroke. Most of these immigration offenders come from the three countries much poorer and much more populous neighbour, Indonesia. But Western visitors also sometimes fall foul of these laws. In 1994 a 45-year-old Frenchman was ordered 5 strokes -- in addition to an 8-month prison term -- for overstaying his visa in Singapore ( Los Angeles Times . 27 October 1994). Caning is optional for many further offences. In Singapore, these include rioting, extortion, living off the earnings of prostitution, manslaughter, and causing hurt. It has also been introduced for a third offence for certain road traffic offences, though there are few reports of this being applied in practice. The offences added most recently (Feb 2008) to the list include joining an unlawful assembly while armed with a deadly weapon, manslaughter, and causing hurt with poison. There are many cases where courts convict, but do not hand down a caning sentence, even where they are empowered to do so. Ill-researched articles sometimes appear in the Western media suggesting that nearly every Singapore court case ends up with a caning sentence. It is evident from available data, such as this table of selected cases , that this is far from the truth. Extension by judicial activism Where the punishment was discretionary, the traditional practice was that it should be imposed only if the offence in question involved a substantial degree of physical violence -- e. g. Lim Thian Han and Others v R Tan Beng Seng v R Chua Ah Seng v R 1953 31 MLJ 213. However, in 1965 in Anwar v PP 1965 31 MLJ 63, the plaintiff had been found guilty of possessing a knuckle duster during a period of racial disturbances, although there was no evidence that he was involved in the riots. The then Chief Justice nevertheless sentenced him to three months imprisonment and 6 strokes of the cane. It was suggested that the main factor in that case was the importance of deterrence at a time when society was afflicted with a serious outbreak of violence. Since the 1990s, moreover, the highest courts have been more inclined to impose sentences of caning where it is not mandatory. Examples are in cases of rape ( Chia Kim Heng Frederick v PP 1992 1 SLR 361) road bullying where grievous hurt results ( PP v Lee Seck Hing 1992 2 SLR 745) hiring of persons to assault another and molesting women. One molest case attracted controversy. 18-year-old Goh Cheng Yew was convicted of molesting a woman in a lift. The Chief Justice not only dismissed his appeal against a six-month prison sentence, but also enhanced it of his own motion by adding three strokes of the cane. Although caning had never been imposed in such cases before, he felt it should be given in view of the increasing incidence of molest cases. The ruling attracted much publicity (All Molesters should be Caned, says CJ, Straits Times . 20 August 1993). As a result, in cases of outraging the modesty of a woman (indecent assault), courts are expected to order a minimum of 9 months imprisonment and three strokes of the cane if the offence involves touching the womans private parts. This benchmark remains in force (Sentencing benchmarks that he set, Straits Times . 1 April 2006). Liability of employees to caning for crimes committed by a company In a few instances, Singapore legislation requires that male employees be caned for offences committed by a company. The Dangerous Fireworks Act requires that a manager, director or owner of a company which deliberately or negligently imports, delivers or sells dangerous fireworks must be caned. Likewise, the manager or director of a company which engages in the business of conveying illegal immigrants must be (in Singapore) or may be (in Malaysia) sentenced to caning if he has authorised, consented to or connived in such activity. As a punishment for breaches of prison discipline As was once the case in Britain itself, several former British territories that still retain corporal punishment permit its infliction for serious breaches of the rules by prisoners in addition to its use as a court sentence for offences against the law. Under Singapores Prisons Act, a prison Superintendent may impose a caning of up to twelve strokes for aggravated prison offences (see table ). This punishment can be imposed after a mini-court hearing within the prison, at which the inmate is given an opportunity to hear the evidence against him and present his defence. As with judicial caning, only men under 50 are liable for internal prison caning. A record must be kept in a register for inspection by the Visiting Justices. If the Superintendent thinks his powers are inadequate in a particular case, he may report the matter in writing to the Visiting Justices, who may award up to 24 strokes. In addition to mutiny or violence against an officer or fellow prisoner, aggravated prison offences include wilful destruction to property wilfully causing to himself any illness, injury or disability wilfully making a false or groundless complaint against any officer or prisoner a third repetition of a minor offence (there are 48 acts which are defined as such) as well as a general clause covering any other act of gross misconduct or insubordination. Prisoners may not engage lawyers to appeal against an internal award of punishment. However, each such order is subject to approval by the Director of Prisons before being carried out. There are no statistics on how often prison discipline caning occurs. 75 aggravated offences were committed in Singapore prisons in 1984, and 66 in 1985. Presumably, for some of these offences at least, caning was imposed, since the 1974 Prisons Reorganisation Committee recommended the imposition of caning for offences which involved the use of violence. The Prisons Department declines to comment on the number of internal prison discipline canings, but claims that such punishment is rare and only imposed on a very small number of inmates who commit serious or aggravated offences. In one 1997 case. five prisoners caught smuggling cannabis into Changi Prison were caned and had their prison terms extended. Normally, though, such cases are not reported in the press and remain unknown to the general public. In 1989, caning powers were extended to Drug Rehabilitation Centres. Section 58(1)(o) of the Misuse of Drugs Act enables the Minister to make regulations providing for the control, discipline (including the imposition of corporal punishment) and occupation of inmates of Drug Rehabilitation Centres. Paragraph 8 of the Regulations made under that Act permits the Superintendent of a Centre to award corporal punishment not exceeding 6 strokes for major offences. These offences are similar to the aggravated prison offences under the Prisons Act, but include in addition bringing any drug, money, intoxicating substance or cigarette into a Centre without permission, or concealing any of these substances in the Centre, and possessing or consuming any drug while on leave from the Centre. A former employee at the Drug Rehabilitation Unit in Changi prison said six strokes were given for drugs in the urine or for homosexuality, and three for fighting (Eye of a Tiger, The Guardian . London, 20 May 1995). It seems likely that similar provisions apply in prisons in Malaysia and Brunei, but information on this is not currently to hand. WHO IS LIABLE TO CANING Caning is normally confined to males aged between 16 and 50. Cases are often reported in which a man escapes the cane simply because he is over 50. In one Singapore case. a man sentenced to jail and caning when he was 49 was able to evade caning by appealing his sentence. Although his appeal failed, the High Court ruled that he could not now be caned because in the meantime he had turned 50. Malaysia has for some time discussed abolishing the upper age limit for rapists, on the grounds that if a man is still fit enough to commit rape he is fit enough to be caned. This change in the law has now been made, and one of the first cases in which a rapist over 50 was sentenced to caning in Malaysia took place in April 2008. a 56-year-old was ordered to receive 12 strokes. No similar change to the law has been reported in Singapore or Brunei. In Singapore, younger teenage offenders may not be caned by the lower courts: The Juvenile Court. has no power to order corporal punishment (Helena H. M. Chan, The Legal System of Singapore . Butterworths Asia, 1995). Part III of the Children and Young Persons Act states: No child or young person shall be sentenced by any court other than the High Court to corporal punishment (s.37(3)). The Singapore High Court, then, is empowered to order the cane for boys under 16. Reports of such cases are rare, but in July 1999 the High Court ordered three 15-year-olds to be caned for offences committed while one of them was still only 14. Three months later the Court went even further, sentencing a boy still only 14 to five years in jail and ten strokes of the cane for kicking and robbing an elderly man. Ten strokes is the maximum for boys under 16 (section 230 of the Criminal Procedure Code) and the caning in such cases is applied with a light rattan (s.229(4)). Some statistics on this are available: 20 juveniles were judicially caned in Singapore in 1998, and 39 in the period Jan to Sep 1999. This latter amounts to about one per week. However, a more recent report DOC suggests that 1999 was a blip: there were 76 juvenile canings in the 4 years from the beginning of 2003 to June 2007, an average of 17 per year. As far as is known, the procedure for caning boys under 16 in Singapore is the same as for adult men apart from the use of the smaller rattan. In this respect generally, however, Singapore has become more like pre-1972 Canada -- where the prison and judicial strap was confined to offenders over 16 -- than pre-1948 Britain, where the great majority of judicial corporal punishments were of boys under 16 (Scotland) or under 14 (England and Wales) and the sentences not combined with imprisonment. The situation in Malaysia and Brunei differs in that local courts do have caning powers over juveniles, and in Malaysia these were actually increased in 1999. with new Childrens Courts being given the power to order up to 10 strokes with a light cane for boys aged between 10 and 18. Ordinary magistrates courts already had this power, but the canings in that case must be given by the boys parent or guardian within court premises. Canings under the Child Act 2001 are to be administered with average force, in the court premises. The boy must remain clothed, and the person administering the cane must not raise his hand over his head, in order that the skin is not cut. The cane must be lifted after each stroke and not pulled. The parent or guardian may be present, if they so wish. In Brunei, the law provides that in the case of a youthful offender, whipping should be inflicted in the way of school discipline with a light rotan. This suggests that here, too, the boy keeps his trousers on. No information seems to be available as to how often these powers are used. Very few such cases are ever mentioned in the press, but that might just be because reporters do not bother to cover juvenile court proceedings. One which was reported involved a boy of 15 the court ordered his father to give him four strokes of the light cane. and this was done immediately. These Malaysian juvenile canings, unlike the adult ones, need not be combined with a prison sentence. Normally, judicial CP gets into the international news only when Western visitors are caned. In Singapore the best-known example is that of Michael Fay in 1994. to whose case we shall return later. But there have been several others. A 48-year-old Dutchman got 6 years plus 10 strokes for importing Ecstasy -- and he wasnt even bringing the drugs to Singapore, merely changing planes on his way to Indonesia. In Malaysia, too, there have been high-profile cases of Westerners receiving caning sentences, especially for drugs offences. Examples include the New Zealander Aaron Cohen and the Australian Robert Symes . Adult caning is never or almost never imposed on its own, but is in addition to a prison sentence. Sometimes a male and a female both commit the same offence and are equally culpable. The female may get a prison sentence but the male will have to suffer a caning in addition to the jail term. Many thousands of men have received this punishment, and the numbers rose inexorably over the years. Some figures for Singapore: 1987: 602 caned (including 115 foreigners) 1988: 616 caned (119 foreigners) 1992: 1,422 caned 1993: 3,244 caned, or over 60 per week. 2006: 5,984 caning sentences (about 95 of which were carried out) 2007: 6,404 caning sentences (about 95 of which were carried out), or about 120 canings per week. But the number of such sentences has fallen dramatically since then, down to only 2,318 in 2011, presumably as a result of a more lenient sentencing policy introduced following a change of Chief Justice in 2006. This information has not, as far as we can discover, been published in Singapore itself, but it appears annually in US State Department Human Rights Reports, so presumably it is correct or the Singapore authorities would surely have challenged it. The 60 a week figure in the 1990s is backed up by a former employee at Changi Jail, who in 1995 said: They are flogging more and more these days. Before they were doing maybe 60 on Tuesdays and Fridays, now theyre doing a hundred (Eye of a Tiger, The Guardian . 20 May 1995). And he was evidently talking about Changi prison alone. I remember one day seeing maybe 60 naked men in Changi waiting to get caned, he added. However, it is possible that this figure includes prison discipline cases as well as court-ordered canings. What these statistics also show is that the great majority of court cases are not covered in the local press, or at least not in the English-language papers, which typically report around three or four caning sentences a week, on average. The most likely explanation is that the majority of canings are of immigration offenders, who usually receive the mandatory minimum of three strokes as well as being fairly briefly imprisoned and then deported. Channel News Asia reported that 11,790 arrests were made in Singapore for immigration offences in 2004 (Nearly 11,800 immigration offenders arrested in 2004, 17 February 2005). An analysis of newspaper reports of caning sentences imposed in Singapore for the period 1997-2000 gives some broad information on this topic, although again it must be stressed that only a fraction of the sentences imposed are reported in the media. During this period about 360 sentences inflicting a total of approximately 3,200 strokes were reported. Of those sentenced: 30 were in their teens (8) 156 in their 20s (43) 108 in their 30s (30) 66 in their 40s (18). Applying these ratios to a possible annual figure of about 3,500 recipients during that period, we can estimate the following numbers caned each year: 16 to 19 year olds: 280 Men in their 20s: 1,505 Men in their 30s: 1,050 Men in their 40s: 630 16 of the Singapore sentences studied imposed 6 strokes, 12 imposed 12 strokes, and 10 imposed 24 strokes, the remainder covering the whole range of odd and even numbers from 1 to 20 strokes. But these figures largely exclude immigration offences. Some Singapore reports refer to dozens of illegal immigrants being sentenced to caning at each court session. The same kind of thing has happened more recently in Malaysia, as in this 2004 case in which about 160 offenders were sentenced, all on one day, to be caned and deported. The usual sentence in such cases is 3 or 4 strokes in Singapore and Brunei, but often only one stroke in Malaysia. In December 2004 it was reported that 18,607 illegal immigrants had been whipped in Malaysia in two years. Only five of these men had received six strokes. 15,214 of them received only one stroke. 11,473 of those caned were Indonesians. In December 2006, Malaysia set up special immigration courts. In the first half of 2007 these new courts sentenced 5,657 immigration offenders to jail terms in special detention centres. 2,922 of these were also caned. Overall JCP statistics for Malaysia do not seem to be available. A 2005 report quoted an official in the state of Sabah as saying that about 60 convicts are caned per week in that state. Sabah contains about 15 of Malaysias population. So if it is typical of the country as a whole, this would suggest some 400 canings a week, or about 21,000 per year. This would be roughly 1 caning per year per thousand inhabitants, broadly similar to the ratio in Singapore. Even less information is available about the frequency of JCP in tiny Brunei. The Associated Press has reported that there were 68 canings in Brunei in 2007 for immigration offences. HOW MANY STROKES ARE GIVEN The Singapore Criminal Procedure Code lays down that 24 strokes is the maximum that can be ordered. Contrary to popular myth, the strokes must all be inflicted on the same occasion, and not in instalments. It is important to be clear that most caning sentences are not of anywhere near 24 strokes. Much more common are sentences of between three and six strokes. (Michael Fays sentence for vandalism was six strokes, reduced in the event to four as an act of clemency.) Press reports of sentences probably give a misleading impression of the norm: the more serious cases are the ones more likely to be reported. As we have seen, the great majority of caning sentences do not get into the media. Most of the more graphic descriptions of the results of judicial caning relate to the more severe sentences and do not really apply when only three or four strokes are given. It was previously thought that 24 strokes was a maximum sentence per trial . but it has recently been clarified by the Law Minister in Parliament that for this purpose per trial means per offence, and the 24-stroke limit per caning is only a general rule following a decision by the Attorney-General in 1990 that 24 strokes are enough of a deterrent measure. The Minister added: There may be a limit of 24 strokes of the cane in any one caning session but that doesnt mean that if he has been tried for different offences, that when hes sent to prison, he may not be receiving different sessions of caning. The same figure of 24 is also the maximum in Malaysia and Brunei. It has been reported that in Malaysia, too, the 24-stroke maximum is per infliction and per warrant, not per trial: if a prisoner is charged under several warrants, he has to serve the combined number of strokes. He can take at the most 24 strokes each time. When the wounds are healed, he has to endure the painful experience all over again. A case was reported in August 2004 in which a rapist was sentenced to 50 strokes in total. In 1991, Quek Kee Chong, 26, sued the Singapore Government for grievous injuries to his buttocks following a 48-stroke caning at Changi jail in April 1988. The court had awarded him 12 strokes on each of four armed robbery charges (Convicted man sues Govt over number of strokes he received, Straits Times . 6 June 1991). Clearly he should not have been given all the strokes at once, and the government later gave him an ex-gratia compensation payment in settlement. Other members of Queks criminal gang have recently made similar claims. saying they too received more than 24 strokes each, but did not realise at the time that this was contrary to the rules. Mr Queks family members said he had later been hospitalised at the Changi Prison Hospital. They were surprised how he withstood the 48 strokes, which, according to informed prison sources, is quite remarkable for a sturdy man to take. THE DIMENSIONS OF THE CANE Punishment canes are made of rattan. Contrary to popular myth, bamboo is not used. Unlike bamboo, rattan is very flexible when wet. The word cane causes some confusion because in American English it usually means a thick, rigid stick, as in a walking stick. A rattan punishment cane is nothing like a walking cane. In some pictures the soaked rattan appears to be so bendy that it may be understandable that some observers are said to have mistakenly thought the implements were actually leather whips. The size and dimensions of the cane are prescribed by regulation. In Singapore, for adult men it is 1.2 metres (4 feet) long, and 1.3cm (half an inch) in diameter (Prison Regulations 132(2)). The Malaysian cane is very slightly smaller, at 1.09m long and 1.25cm thick. A smaller cane, the light rattan, is used for boys under 16, in both Singapore and Malaysia. The dimensions of Singapores light rattan are not known. It could be similar to the Singapore school cane, which is only slightly shorter than the judicial cane but a good deal thinner. In Malaysia, it has been revealed that the juvenile light rattan is also used for non-violent white-collar offenders, those convicted of criminal breach of trust -- embezzlement and the like (Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Act 1994). It has been described as about half the size of the standard rotan. This seems to be an exaggeration. The following picture, from a display at Johor Baru prison, shows one longer and two shorter canes, and the shorter ones are only a few inches shorter than the longer one, but also somewhat thinner. Malaysia, but not Singapore, also has separate Islamic religious courts administering Sharia (Syariah) law, applicable only to Moslems. This operates in parallel with the mainstream judicial system. Its provisions vary in detail from one state to another and do not primarily concern criminal matters but, when they do, canings are occasionally ordered for such sins as adultery or drinking alcohol. (In practice this sort of thing appears to happen only in the conservative rural northern states. where Islam is much stronger than in KL or the other heavily westernised urban centres on the west coast.) These are carried out in prisons by the same officers who administer the ordinary judicial canings. But, here again, it is the smaller rotan that is used, and it is applied with much less force, the aim being a symbolic act of shame rather than serious physical pain. The prisoner is strapped to a large wooden trestle. The type used in Singapore is clearly closely based on, if not identical with, the British dual-purpose prison flogging frame, originally designed for both floggings with the cat on the upper back (offender standing upright) and punishments applied to the posterior (offender bending over). The Singapore trestle seen in a recent government anti-crime video, Prison Me No Way, is specially made and painted blue. It is like two Hs joined at the top and extended at the base to about three feet. There is a timber base, comprising four pieces of timber joined to form a rectangle, on which the prisoner stands in his bare feet. On his side of the trestle there are two horizontal bars. The upper crossbar is slightly padded and adjustable, so that in position it is at the level of his waist. The padding is like a sheepskin or piece of foam wrapped around a piece of timber. The lower crossbar has bolted to it two short lengths of chain, each of four links to which are attached, by D-rings, restraining ankle cuffs. These are of black leather, with chrome fittings they are about two inches wide with smaller tightening straps. On the opposite side of the trestle there is a stabilising crossbar, higher up, and another crossbar placed slightly lower than the adjustable one on the prisoners side. Attached to this crossbar are wrist cuffs, similar to the ankle cuffs. When the prisoners wrists are attached to these cuffs his hands are able to hold on to this crossbar. The Singapore Director of Prisons said: . it is essential that the leather be strong . the prisoner struggles violently after each of the first three strokes . In some reports the cuffs are stated to be of rubber. Possibly, different equipment is used in different institutions. It can be seen from several pictures of dummy demonstration canings that very similar equipment is used in Brunei. In Malaysia, on the other hand, the frame (pictured right) is a triangle rather than a trestle, coming to a point at the top instead of having parallel sides. The convict does not bend over but must stand upright. A specially designed protective shield is placed round the torso, leaving only the buttocks exposed. It is not known when or why this different approach was adopted in Malaysia. THE MEDICAL EXAMINATION It is a requirement that the prisoner be medically fit to be caned. At the beginning of the official Malaysian caning video. the prison doctor and his assistant are seen carrying out a medical examination on a prisoner about to receive punishment. The Singapore Criminal Procedure Code, Section 231(1) provides: The punishment of caning shall not be inflicted unless a medical officer is present and certifies that the offender is in a fit state of health to undergo such punishment. There is no appeal against the MOs decision that the prisoner is fit to be caned ( Tam Eng Chye v Director of Prisons . Attorney-Generals Annual Report 20045 PDF, p.9). The doctor has the power to stop the punishment at any time, and his duties include medical treatment on its completion. In the Malaysian video it is seen that each recipient is taken to the prison hospital immediately the caning is over, where he lies face down on a bed and has his buttocks cleaned up and disinfected. In Singapore the post-caning treatment is said to include the painting-on of gentian violet, a disinfectant which dyes the skin temporarily purple (possibly making the damage look worse than it actually is). However, some Singapore recipients, including Michael Fay, report being taken straight back to their cells without any immediate medical attention (though later he got some sort of dressing on his wounds). One might infer that first aid is not always deemed necessary after only a few strokes. High blood pressure or heart problems are said to be grounds for exemption in Malaysia. A report in 2003 stated that, out of 19 prisoners being whipped on a particular day at a jail in Sarawak, three (about 15) were found medically unfit. As we have seen, however, in Singapore it has been stated that 95 of caning sentences are actually inflicted. CANING SESSIONS IN PRISON In both Singapore and Malaysia, canings are inflicted so frequently that there are regular sessions at which groups of men are dealt with together. The men are made to squat in a line outside the caning room to await their turn. According to a former Singapore prison employee interviewed in 1994, these sessions are normally held every Tuesday and Friday at Changi, the famous top-security jail. But there are also other jails, notably Queenstown Remand Prison, where the American teenager Michael Fay was caned in May 1994 for vandalism. Prisoners are not told in advance when their caning is to take place. Fay was one of a group of ten inmates punished that Thursday afternoon: Fay was led from his cell to a waiting room, along with nine other inmates. He said About 2.30 p. m. they brought me down a hall handcuffed. After his number was called, he was taken into the punishment area. Others have described as waiting their turn in groups of ten or even twenty men. Presumably, sometimes there will be a long wait, particularly if there is a large batch of men and if a number of 15 or 24 stroke sentences have to be inflicted. Having to wait no doubt adds to the fear and apprehension of the occasion. Peter (not his real name), who received 10 strokes in Changi Prison for gang offences, recalled his experience in a 1991 newspaper interview: That morning, about 10 of us were called up for a medical check-up. Nobody told us what it was for but we knew. The anxiety began when we were led back to our cells after the check up. I kept thinking of the unwritten law. No begging and no screaming. I kept reminding myself. After lunch and a short break, our group was led to the caning compound. All 10 of us were made to squat while waiting in a corridor. The wait was terrible. We were all hoping to be called first, to get it over and done with. At least you dont have to see the others suffer and be even more scared. Another man, Sam, who received 15 strokes for rape, described his experience: (I was) three months into my prison term when the day of the caning came. There were about twenty of us all lined up in a row outside a room where we were going to be caned. I was number 6. We were all in shorts and singlets. Another prisoner, Ah Seng, described his wait: I was very frightened. I had heard how painful caning was and also what one suffered after the caning. INSIDE THE CANING AREA This tiny picture from an official Youth Crime CD-ROM produced in the 1990s is the only known photograph of an actual judicial caning under way in Singapore. (NOTE: Contrary to some press reports, the CD-ROM contains only small stills, not a video of a caning.) The room in the picture is large and has a very high ceiling. There is a polished floor. At the end of the room there are tables at which senior prison staff are seated to view the infliction. At the other end of the room is the caning trestle. It is perhaps 9 feet high, solidly constructed from timber, on a wooden base on which the prisoner stands. It is not known where this photo was taken. Perhaps it is Changi jail. Michael Fays caning at Queenstown Road Remand Prison, however, took place -- according to the transcript of a later TV interview with Fay -- not in a room at all, but in an open-air prison yard that was partially protected from a tropical downpour by a covering over the trestle to which he was bound. Here is a computer-enhanced version of another picture from the CD. This shows the prisoner from behind as he is strapped into the frame, during or immediately after the punishment. Here it is just possible to discern the raw and bleeding flesh of the lower buttock area, particularly the right buttock, with some blood trickling down the thigh. Compare these pictures with the following diagram from the government-controlled Straits Times of 1 May 1994, headed How a Prisoner is Caned, part of an article entitled Prisons Department sets the facts straight on caning. One respect in which the artist of the above drawing seems to have got it significantly wrong is in showing the offenders feet spread wide apart, with the ankles strapped to the side legs of the frame. The photos show the legs in fact fairly close together, as in pre-1965 British prison birchings. This ensures that the genitalia are not accidentally hit from behind. In Malaysian prisons, the punishment is inflicted in an open yard, as we see in these video clips. The main difference with Singapore is that the prisoner stands upright, and his legs are placed apart (see picture at right). The danger of hitting the genitals is avoided by the use of a special torso shield, which covers the mans lower body, exposing only the buttocks themselves. Judicial caning involves a formal, ritualised ceremony. Uniformed officers are in attendance, and orders are given by the senior officer. Although canings are inflicted out of sight of other prisoners, there are several prison officers in attendance, including the superintendent, a superintendent warder, prison officers, the doctor and male nurse or assistants, and the officers administering the caning. Victims have described how sometimes the caning officer will be practising on a dummy while the prisoner is being prepared. Peter described being called in for his turn: When my name was called, I tried to pretend everything was under control. But I couldnt walk properly and my T-shirt was wet with sweat. The sound of the warder flexing the cane made it worse. When it was my turn to go in, I saw six men in the room: two police officers, a doctor, and three men -- the ones administering the caning. I also saw a cluster of rotans THE CANING OFFICERS The caning officers are specially trained. They are all robustly built and some hold quite high grades in martial arts, though official sources have denied that this is a requirement. Michael Fay described the warder who administered his caning as young, very fit. Sam remembered his caner as muscular. The official interviewed by Maggie OKane of The Guardian in 1995 (Eye of a Tiger, 20 May) was only in his early twenties but had already retired from the job. The officers are put though a period of training before they are accredited. The chief caner is always present at these training sessions, and often a doctor is there too. The aim is to inflict maximum pain with the least permanent damage. Caning is practised on sandbags, dummies or banana trees. The caners wear a T-shirt or similar costume as freedom of movement is essential. One former caning operative has said that in the 1960s he was paid SGD 1 for each prisoner caned. The largest number of strokes he could remember delivering in one session was 60. By 1990 the sum paid was SGD 10 to SGD 20 per flogging, plus SGD 20 (about euro10) per month on top of the normal prison officers salary ( The Caning of Michael Fay by Gopal Baratham, p.108). Nick Rogue Trader Leeson claimed that the Singapore caners are bodybuilders, who are paid SGD 2 for every stroke ( Daily Mail . London, 10 July 1999). However, Leeson was probably merely retailing prison gossip. He is not necessarily a reliable source, and neither, certainly, is the Daily Mail . In Malaysia, where canings take place at numerous prisons in the various states, there are some 50 flogging officers nationwide. The bonus paid to them was increased in 2005 from MYR 3 per stroke (less than one euro) to MYR 10 per stroke (nearly euro3). At Kajang prison, canings are scheduled for every Wednesday and Friday. Selecting and training caning officers is said to be a long and difficult process. out of 30 candidates among prison officers, only two may be selected following a test of their strength, precision, consistency and movement of their strokes and their discipline, attitude and team spirit. PROCEDURE IN DETAIL The Singapore Prisons Regulations require that caning be inflicted on the buttocks (Regulation 132(2)). In practice the prisoner is required to strip completely naked for the administration of the punishment. A former prison officer has stated that, before the caning, the prisoners name is read out to ensure he is the correct person. The offence and the prescribed punishment is read out so the prisoner can confirm it. (The same precautions are taken in Malaysia, as shown in the official video.) Once he has removed his clothes, the inmate is made to stand facing the trestle so that he can be tied to it. In Singapore, he is made to bend over a pad between the front legs. His feet are secured to the front base with his hands secured to the back legs, so that he is bent over at about right angles at the hip. As the Straits Times described it in 1974, he bends over with his bottoms sic up, ready to receive his punishment. A pillow or cushion is secured across the small of his back to protect the vulnerable kidney area from a mis-stroke. Michael Fay said they stripped me and put rubber-lined padding around my sides, leaving the buttocks bare. Otherwise I was completely naked (interview in Newsweek . 4 July 1994). The prisoner is not gagged. Qwek Shi Lei, the then Director of Prisons, gave more details at a press conference in 1974. Prisoners, he said, are frightened that they will be unable to stop themselves crying out. They want to be able to take their punishment like a man, and crying means a loss of face. (Face is a big deal in Asian cultures.) Once the prisoner is secured, the caning officer will take up position, standing about five feet away, and adjusting his position with the aid of the cane. According to Mr Qwek . correct positioning is critical. If he is too near the prisoner, the tip of the cane will fall beyond the buttocks and thus reduce the effect of the stroke. If he is too far, the stroke will only cover part of the buttocks. A senior officer stands by, with the doctor. The cane is soaked overnight in water, so it is supple. The Prisons Department says this is to prevent it from splitting and shearing the skin. They denied earlier claims that the cane is soaked in brine. However, it is treated with antiseptic before use. A former flogger interviewed by Gopal Baratham has specified more precisely that it is the front third of the cane that is soaked in fluid to make it supple, producing the effect of a lash the back third is rigid so the caner has greater control (op. cit. p.105). Once the caning officer is in position and the order given to proceed, the strokes are called out: One Two, etc. by a warder. Michael Fay said they go Count one -- you hear them yell it really loud -- and a few seconds later they come. Each stroke is delivered after the call of the count. The blows are delivered at intervals of about thirty seconds. Sometimes two caning officers take turns to administer the strokes. CRIMINAL WHIPPING VS SYARIAH WHIPPING FOR A SYARIAH WHIPPING, the officer must exercise restraint and keep the upper arm close to the body. The rotans end is held at the height of the offenders head. The rotan swings downwards with only a movement of the wrist. -- PHOTOS: NEW STRAITS TIMES Irrespective of the age of the offender or the type of crime committed, every stroke is inflicted with the full strength of the warder: Canings are administered with maximum force ( South China Morning Post . Hong Kong, 2 April 1994). . when caning, the warder uses the whole of his body weight, and not just the strength of his arms, to strike. He holds the cane rigidly at arms length and pivots on his feet to deliver the stroke. (Singapore Director of Prisons, September 1974) A 25-year-old caning officer in Malaysian prisons, Iskandar Radz, said that he underwent a two-week training course during which he was taught how to swing the 1.09-metre cane at a minimum speed of 160kph and produce a force upon impact of at least 90kg. Apparently different techniques are permitted: . there were those who twirled and those who took a breath and took careful aim. There were those who took three steps forward and those who stood absolutely still. It was all a matter of individual style some played a serve and volley game and some preferred to play from the base line, some used a type of top spin, others preferred the quick smash. They were allowed to use the method they liked best. Individual preference was respected (Baratham, p.107). Others have said . the caner was remarkably good. No two strokes inflicted by him fell on the same spot. It was one slightly above or below the other. The caning was implemented with machine-like precision . . . my men were trained using dummies with chalk lines on their buttocks. The timing and aim of the stroke had to be just right, just like a golf swing . Michael Fay stated . the caner did not run, but rather walked sharply forward three steps so he can get a little power behind him. The caner in the photo from the CD-ROM, on the other hand, appears to be launching into a sort of flying leap. The photo sequence on the right, from the Straits Times of 3 July 2005, shows a Malaysian prison officer demonstrating his caning technique. The accompanying article quotes prison officer Wahid, 35, who metes out 100 strokes in an average week at Kajang Prison in Selangor, near Kuala Lumpur: Under the criminal penal code, the whipping officer must use as much force as he can muster during the caning. The power behind an ordinary whipping comes from the wrist, arm, shoulder and the swing. Whipping convicts is much more difficult (than administering a Syriah caning) because you have to do it with a lot of power. The harder, the better. If he holds back even one notch, the officer fails in his duty. Thats why all whipping officers are tall and big bodied. You have to be very focused because there is a very small area to hit. When you have made contact with the buttocks, you must drag the tip of the rotan along the skin to break it. It could be the use of this dragging technique to deliberately break the skin, as much as the size of the cane and the force with which it is used, that makes judicial caning so much more severe in its effects than school caning. THE IMMEDIATE PHYSICAL EFFECTS Eyewitnesses and others have reported on the severity of the canings: The blows are applied with the full force of the jailers arm. When the rattan hits the bare buttocks, the skin disintegrates, leaving a white line and then a flow of blood. (Singapore Bar Association report) I . saw blood at the fourth stroke. The prisoner slumped over in evident terrible pain. The caning stopped (Caning -- the most dreaded punishment. Straits Times . 7 September 1974). The skin at the point of contact is usually split open and, after three strokes, the buttocks will be covered in blood. (Singapore Director of Prisons, September 1974) Left: Asiaweek published this picture purportedly of bleeding immediately after a Malaysian caning (number of strokes unknown). Compare with the results seen as canings progress in the Malaysian official video. The skin did rip open, there was some blood, said Michael Fay of his four-stroke caning. adding Lets not exaggerate, and lets not say a few drops or that the blood was gushing out. It was in between the two. Its like a bloody nose. The Prisons Department has denied allegations that the cane causes skin and flesh to fly. But they conceded that it does leave bruises and marks. This contradicts earlier statements in the government-controlled press. The New Paper . apparently rehashing reports of the famous 1974 press conference, did report in 1992 that Pieces of skin and flesh fly at each stroke. A US analyst has suggested that these earlier accounts may have been deliberately exaggerated in the hope of deterring delinquents (Singapores Relations With U. S. Still Sore, Washington Post . 14 May 1994). Another explanation for some of the apparent discrepancies between different accounts may simply be that not enough distinction has been made between canings of just a few strokes and those at or near the maximum of 24. For a very much more gruesome illustration of what appears to be the immediate aftermath of a caning of a large number of strokes, probably in Malaysia, see the JCP Pictures page (warning: not for the squeamish). Thus, when Gopal Baratham asked a former flogger Does the skin break and the flesh fly, the reply was, Always after fifteen strokes, however accurate the flogger, the skin will be gone and the flesh will fly (op. cit. p.119). The Singapore authorities could therefore perhaps claim that many of the more lurid media descriptions ahead of Michael Fays punishment were exaggerations when applied to what was to be only a six-stroke caning (reduced at the last minute to four). But then it is they or their predecessors, and particularly Prisons Director Qwek in 1974, who were the original source of most of these descriptions. If its a well-trained caner, the skin across the whole backside will split 99 per cent of the time. The well-trained caner will whack on different spots, avoiding already open wounds. (This produces the most pain with the least scarring). The cane leaves huge red welts and permanent scars ( Straits Times . 8 April 1994). REACTION OF THE PRISONER TO THE CANING The Director of Prisons said at his 1974 press conference that most prisoners put up a struggle after each of the first three strokes. He continued After that their struggles lessen as they become weaker. At the end of the caning those who receive more than three lashes are usually in a state of shock. Many will collapse, but the medical officer and his team of assistants are on hand to revive them and to apply antiseptic to the caning wounds. Many will pretend to faint, but they cannot fool the prison doctor whose presence is legally required. Michael Fay said that a prison officer stood beside him and guided him through the ordeal, saying: Okay Michael, three left. Okay Michael, two left. Okay one more, youre almost done. He was later told that he shouted out Im dying when the first stroke hit but he could not remember crying out. Fay did not recall hearing the caner say one word throughout the whole procedure. One of the floggers interviewed by Gopal Baratham said, Most are silent, but some pray, some beg for mercy, others scream (op. cit. p.107). Nick Leeson was not caned but he says his two cellmates were. He reported: It causes an awful lot of trauma to the body. People shake and shake. They cant stop themselves. The inmates are not allowed to utter a sound when theyre flogged if they want to keep face. Five lashes basically leave no unbroken skin on the backside, so if youre having 24 your backside is a mess. But you cannot scream. DESCRIPTIONS OF THE EXPERIENCE BY MEN WHO HAVE BEEN CANED It is the clear intention of the authorities that the caning be as painful as possible, and, judging from the descriptions of men who have personally experienced it, this aim is achieved. Neveille Tan, now a pastor in his sixties, received a total of 30 strokes on three occasions in 1958, 1959 and 1966 in Changi Prison. In his memoirs Iron Man he described the excruciating pain of a thick cane landing forcefully on soft flesh: He was a tall Indian man with a black moustache which twirled upwards at both ends. He looked fierce and strong. His arms were huge as I glanced at them through eyes of fear and tension. In his right hand was the cane, about as thick as the size of my thumb. He was flexing it, bending it and taking swings at the air with it. Each time he swung the cane it whistled. I began to imagine how much it would hurt when it landed on my bare backside. Two warders (prison guards) were busy strapping me on to a contraption that looked like a huge broadside letter A. One of them was strapping a canvas pad just above my buttocks. When he finished, he strapped another pad just below my buttocks to expose only the main part of my backside. By now my heart was pounding inside my chest. I gritted my teeth and prepared to receive the first stroke of the cane. This was the first time I was going to be whipped. My legs began to tremble and my heart pounded furiously as I heard the superintendent of prisons (the warden) reading the court order for me to be whipped with six strokes of the cane. The prison doctor, a thin turbaned Sikh with a stethoscope around his neck, was giving me the final look over. Are you OK he asked me as he pressed his stethoscope on my chest and back. Breathe in he ordered me. OK he asked again. I nodded. I could hear some movement behind me then I heard the voice of the Superintendent of prisons ordering the whipping to begin. Satu which in Malay means one he began the slow count . I heard the whizzing sound of the cane as it whizzed its way towards my bare buttocks. I heard the sharp cracking sound like the sound of a small pistol shot as it landed square, right across the tender flesh of my behind. There was no pain at first, just a warm burning sensation but slowly, as feeling returned, the heat became unbearably painful. It felt as if a red-hot poker had been pressed against my backside. I felt my flesh tingling and then came the throbbing pain. That was only the first stroke. I gritted my teeth as I heard the voice of the Superintendent calling out the second number in Malay - Dua as the second stroke landed, I found myself shivering with the pain. Every nerve in my body seemed to be reacting to the sting. The pain was now excruciating. Enam (six) came the count. Again, I heard the horrible whizzing sound of the descending cane through the air. My whole backside was now totally swollen. The pain had become extremely excruciating. The officer who was administering the whipping was not supposed to hit me on the same spot twice, but he did. I felt like I was ready to black out, but I forced myself to remain conscious and fought back the engulfing darkness. Even then, barely conscious, my pride was still strong. It would be shameful if I could not take even six strokes of the cane. I was not going to let them see my pain. I gritted my teeth so hard that my jaws felt stiff and ached. Then it was all over. I had received the full six strokes, my first six strokes of the cane. They untied me and as I tried to straighten myself, my legs were so wobbly that they almost buckled. It was over. The male nurse swabbed a dark violet blue lotion over my raw backside and I was ushered out of the room. Later in the book he describes the time when he was awarded 12 strokes for assaulting another inmate: (I was sentenced to) solitary confinement for fourteen days and twelve strokes of the cane. Two days later, the prison doctor visited my cell. He was the same, skinny, turbaned Sikh doctor who had attended to me when I was in Changi prison. You again he greeted me. And this time twelve He shook his head as he placed his stethoscope on my chest. He listened for a while and then said No problem lah Twenty-four also can, he smirked and with that, he left. I thought they would at least wait until my arm was totally healed. But that was not to be. The next day I was called out of my cell again and into the familiar room and strapped onto the same contraption as I received another twelve strokes of the cane . I laid face down on the floor naked from the waist down. I could feel liquid oozing from my wounds but I was too weak to pay any attention to it. That day, I refused to bathe. In the exercise yard, I just leaned against the wall and glared into the sky. I was drained of all emotions. What had I done. How did I get myself into this situation Had I buried myself in prison for good The days dragged by very slowly. Finally I counted that there would be only two days left before I would be released from solitary confinement. My backside had healed though the scabs were still there. I could wear my shorts now but there was still some bleeding every now and then. My wound was also beginning to itch but I was careful not to itch it. Further descriptions, from more recent times, are equally graphic: I waited for the first blow to land, biting my teeth hard and closing my eyes. I heard the cane crack and felt blood shoot right through my body. The pain was beyond description. If there is a word stronger than excruciating, that should be the word to describe it. (10 strokes) Someone said count one and he took three steps, swinging (the cane) back and forth, before hitting me on the third step. You hear a crack when it hits you. About a second went by and then it just burned all through my body. And it hurts, it does hurt. I felt a deep burning sensation throughout my body, real pain. My flesh was ripped open. (Michael Fay, 4 strokes) It sounded like a tree falling onto my buttocks. First, a stinging blow to my buttocks and when the cane was lifted, I could feel blood shooting up from my body. The pain was unbearable. And it got more painful. my body shook with pain (Sam, 15 strokes) If I was not tied up during the caning, I would have climbed up the wall with my bare hands (Jack, 20 strokes). The first stroke came. the pain was unbelievable and there were still five to go. There was pain in my whole body. Only my hair didnt feel pain. I thought nothing could be worse than that until the second stroke hit me. Then I really thought I was going to die. By the time the third came, my whole body was just a lump of pain and the other two strokes did not make any difference (Ah Seng, 5 strokes, interviewed by Baratham, p.111 ff.). Another warder stripped me and strapped me to a wooden trestle by my ankles and wrists. By then I was already shivering and perspiring with fear. Then I heard the cane. It sounded like a plank hitting the wall. A split second later, I felt it tearing across my buttocks. I screamed and struggled like a mad animal. All I thought was that I wanted to run away. If Im not tied up, one stroke could keep me running for a mile. It went on and on, one stroke one minute. Some lashes fell on the same spot, splitting open the skin even more. I felt giddy and went limp on the trestle at the last stroke. My bleeding buttocks throbbed with pain and felt like they were on fire. After we were flogged, a medical officer applied some antiseptic on the wounds. My buttocks then swelled to twice their normal size. My thighs went blue-black. I had to go without shorts for more than two weeks so that my wounds could heal. I couldnt sit on my buttocks or sleep on my back or bathe all this time either (Account of unidentified prisoner caned at age 17, New Paper, Singapore, 12 October 1988). Another description was broadcast on the Voice of America on 21 March 1994: (Reporter:) Miss Jones remembers the trauma reported by one man who came to Amnesty International after several strokes of the cane: he was shivering and perspiring with fear just before. and then during the caning, he remembers how it felt. it was like a tearing across his buttocks. he talked about how he screamed like a mad animal and how basically, it leaves festering and huge scars on his derriere. it swelled to twice its size and he was not able for weeks and weeks to wear clothing. The tremendous bruising black and blue of thighs. And he says to this day he still has nightmares about it. This happened when he was seventeen. Hes now over 40. This isnt just a little spanking. This is truly traumatic. It may be easy for people to say oh, this is simply a little pain and itll go away. If one has undergone it, I think one can really understand the cruelty of it. Every stroke was a stroke of hell, which I will never forget as long as I live. Malaysian judicial canings have provoked very similar first-person descriptions. Aaron Cohen recalled his caning : I got six. Its just incredible pain. More like a burning -- like someone sticking an iron on your bum. Thats the sort of feeling. Pain -- just ultimate pain. . The strokes came at the rate of one a minute -- but it seemed like a lifetime to me. I waited and waited for the first one and as soon as I let my breath out -- Baamm. Afterwards my bum looked like a side of beef. There was three lines of raw skin with blood oozing out. Another lively account of being flogged in a Malaysian prison is to be found in Robert Symess 1991 article in Penthouse . Symes received six strokes in 1982 for drug-trafficking. Once the final stroke is delivered, the prisoner is unbuckled from the trestle and given medical treatment: The doctor puts that purple medicine (gentian violet) on the wounds and they go back to their cells. They paint some medicine on the flogged area and send the inmate back to his cell. They get the stuff out of a bucket, and paint it like a mans backside is a wall. When it is over, the wounds are treated with the antiseptic, gentian violet, and for weeks the prisoner cannot sit down. After the fifteenth stroke, they untied him and told him to go, after the doctor applied a medicated lotion on his buttocks. He was also given a bottle of lotion. When necessary, dressings are applied to cover the wounds. Michael Fay reported that a doctor changed the dressings on his wounds every day. Alex, who received three strokes for vandalism in November 1994, wrote: The day I was caned, I weighed about 132 pounds. That was about 40 days after admission. The pain was a bit killing but I was all right and there was no blood just after caning, so the attendant medic did not apply the blue lotion on my buttock. I have no experience so I sat on the floor to cool the buttock. Then the skin split and blood came out. He said that the blood just wet his shorts but there was not excessive bleeding. Most of the others caned on that day had blue lotion applied. It took about 2 weeks or longer to heal, because we were not given medicine or lotion. Also when we assembled, we squatted down. This caused the skin scar to part and blood will come out. For this reason, he said, men who have been caned seek to be excused from squatting at gate landings while moving about the prison. Nick Leeson when in Tumah Marah Prison recalled fellow inmates being caned: Some people say the easiest way to get over it is to go back to the hall where the floor is very hot and just sit on it to cauterise the wound (Repentance of a Rogue Trader, Daily Mail . London, 10 July 1999). After he is unshackled and treated, the prisoner is taken back to his cell to recover. Peter recalled that after 10 strokes, he was unable to walk without help from the warder: As I was being led out of the caning compound, I caught a glimpse of the used canes. They were split and bloody. They even had pieces of skin stuck on them. Some were probably mine. Some prisoners in Singapore are taken to the prison hospital after their caning. In Malaysia this appears to be routine for all caned prisoners. AFTER EFFECTS: THE HEALING OF THE WOUNDS This tiny picture (right), taken from the above-mentioned CD-ROM, gives a glimpse of the wounded backsides of two young offenders some time (it is not clear how long) after a Singapore caning. The photograph on the left (click it to enlarge), found on a Malaysian government (prison service) website, was originally captioned Kesan luka hukuman sebat (marks of wounds from caning punishment). It appears to show the position after bleeding has stopped but before the wounds have started to heal, so probably within a few days of the caning. The following picture was on display at the Johor Baru prison exhibition: This, too, was probably taken relatively shortly after these prisoners were caned. It is interesting to note how different the wounds can be from one case to another, even allowing for different numbers of strokes. The wounds of caning take some weeks to heal. Here are some descriptions of the after-effects by men who have been caned. My buttocks felt as if they were burning. They swelled to twice their normal size. I could not sit down or lie on my back. I couldnt even walk properly. The skin on (my) buttocks peeled off and (my) backside was completely bruised. It bled on and off for days . (I had to) put on an apron for about ten days as I could not wear shorts. (I was) also unable to sit. Immediately after the caning (I had to lie on my) stomach for about four hours. For two hours (I even had) difficulty standing up . Going to the toilet was the worst . you dont dare to squat because you may tear open the wounds again. So you try to do it half sitting and half squatting (Jack - 20 strokes). I stumbled to an adjacent room and plonked myself down. For the next three weeks (I) slept with my face down. (I) could neither eat or sleep properly. For the first week, I couldnt even sleep. The pain was unbearable. It took more than a month for the wounds to dry. My buttocks didnt look normal after that, with the skin drooping and the scars (Sam - 15 strokes). (After the caning) I couldnt sit down or lie on my back for a week. (Going to the toilet) was the worst of all . I could not squat or even bend my knees. I got scared every time I got the urge . I tried not eating but this did not work. I still had to go and I had to do this standing up, holding my buttocks wide apart. (This lasted) one week then things came back to normal (Ah Seng - 5 strokes). The wounds take between a week and a month to heal. During that time many cannot sit or sleep on their backs and dare not bathe for fear of getting sores. The wounds heal but the marks are indelible. The caners are supposed to be so skilful that they never hit the same spot twice ( Sunday Times . Singapore, 13 July 1986). My buttocks swelled a little bit . the wounds hurt for about five days after which they itched as they healed. The first couple of days it was very hard to sit. Now about six weeks after the caning on one side there are three dark brown scar patches on my right buttock, and four lines each about 1.2cm wide on my left buttock, where the flesh was torn (Michael Fay - 4 strokes). According to statements by Michael Fays father and one of his lawyers, the US diplomat who saw him in prison, shortly after the caning, was allowed to inspect the damage. Fay was reported to be bleeding through bandages over his buttocks. When the bandages were removed the diplomat is said to have observed that the flesh was ripped and broken, there were circular wounds, about two inches in diameter, where it appeared there was more serious damage, where the cane had struck twice. Fay senior also claimed that the diplomat had reported that Mike had a great deal of difficulty in walking, but he was able to sit down at one point, although again it was with a great deal of difficulty. His face was contorted. He was in pain, and when he sat down, he sat down very gingerly (Caned Youth Gets Visit In Singapore, New York Times . 7 May 1994). However, these are second - or third-hand impressions: the diplomat himself had declined to say anything to the press except that, not being a doctor, he was not qualified to make a judgement about Fays condition. At all events the Singapore authorities disputed these quoted accounts, dismissing Fay seniors remarks as wild allegations and misinformation and saying that Fay sat, laughed and smiled during the visit, and wanted his father to shut up about the caning. They also claimed that Fay said the caning was not as bad and horrifying as described in the press ( USA Today . 9 May 1994 Washington Post . 8 May 1994). But then, as Gopal Baratham has written, There are rumours that the caner was asked to go lightly on the boy so that the lashing did not leave permanent scars on his buttocks, scars that he could expose to the American media: scars that would do more harm to Singapores international image than they had done to Fays behind (op. cit. p.22). According to Nick Leeson, My cellmates had five strokes each. They lay on their front for two days. It basically takes two weeks to heal (Repentance of a Rogue Trader, Daily Mail . London, 10 July 1999). Caning as described above will produce permanent scars, according to several reports. In an NBC documentary shown in 1994, a former prisoner was shown raising his sarong and exposing his bottom to the camera - the scars of his caning were clearly visible. Likewise, The New Paper in 1991 published the following picture of the buttocks of an ex-convict who, it said, had been caned 10 years previously: And in Gopal Barathams book, two pictures are reproduced - in fact almost certainly different views of the same man: The Singapore Director of Prisons in his 1974 news conference said: . the cane marks are indelible and these will be a source of humiliation to (the prisoners) for the rest of their lives. Reporting on the news conference, the Straits Times . in an article called Branding the Bad Hats for Life. stated on 13 September 1974: The Director of Prisons . yesterday gave a graphic, blow-by-blow account of how criminals are caned so they will walk with scarred bottoms for the rest of their lives. Jack and Peter, both caned in the early 1980s, told the New Paper that the caning had affected them in their life after prison, and how they had to find excuses to explain away the marks. Men who have been caned are not permitted to serve in the Singapore Armed Forces. After the 1974 news conference, one Singapore paper took up the issue of scarring in an editorial. suggesting that . marking a criminal for life -- even on a spot not immediately visible to others -- smacks of barbaric medievalism. The editorial also criticised the whole tone of the Prisons Directors press conference. (Clearly the local newspapers were less rigidly controlled by the regime in 1974 than they are now: even this muted degree of criticism is never found in the Singapore press today.) However, it is not certain that the marks last forever in cases where relatively few strokes were administered. The following photograph of 20-year-old Dickson Tans bottom was taken just one year after his 8-stroke caning: Dickson Tan, who was caned for helping an illegal money lender, displays his bruises for the camera in Singapore March 27, 2008. Tan is suing the Singapore government for around S3 million (USD 2.2 million) in damages for mistakenly caning him three more strokes than he was sentenced to. court documents showed. REUTERSVivek Prakash Despite what the Reuters caption says, we see no bruises here, only weals. Any bruises had already disappeared. In fact this looks at first glance just like an ordinary schoolboy caning, until we remember that it is 12 months after the event. Even so, it is not obvious that this relatively moderate scarring is going to be there for life. HUMILIATION AND DETERRENCE Judicial caning is clearly intended to be a humiliating experience. Former Prime Minister Lee Kwan Yew, founding father of modern Singapore, introducing mandatory caning for vandalism in 1966, told Parliament: . if (the offender) knows he is going to get three of the best, I think he will lose a great deal of enthusiasm, because there is little glory attached to the rather humiliating experience of having to be caned. (Lee, now Minister Mentor, always seems to refer to the subject in this oddly juvenile vein -- three of the best, and so on -- as if to suggest, though he surely cannot seriously believe, that the punishments in question are somehow equivalent to the headmasters canings he received as a schoolboy at Raffles College in the 1930s, which he mentions in his memoirs.) In fact, the severity and humiliation of the punishment are widely publicised: compulsory prison visits for juvenile delinquents include viewing what newspapers have described as a film of the execution of the punishment (though it is not known whether such a film really exists for Singapore) as well as a real-life demonstration by a warder on a dummy. The films of Malaysian canings were evidently made by the authorities with a similar aim in mind. One newspaper article stated in 1974. In the Singapore context, caning is the most dreaded form of punishment. If proof be needed, I need only recall the very many instances when young and middle-aged offenders, under caning orders, begged the Appeal Court in vain to suspend them and give longer prison terms instead. (But) until Parliament changes the law, there is nothing that can be done. There is, indeed, little sympathy expressed towards those being caned. A writer from the National University of Singapore defended the punishment: . it is a part of the law that most Singaporeans are glad to give their support . the purpose of caning is to inflict pain. For this purpose, the safest place to cane is really the buttock, and none other . According to accounts given by people who have been caned, they suffered immense pain during the caning, and would not be able to sit or lie down on their buttocks for many days, even up to two weeks. And the surface of the skin may split open during the caning. Thats all The result of caning is a lasting mark on their buttocks. This serves a lasting educational purpose they will always be reminded not to commit the offence again Although the extensive use of corporal punishment in Singapore is a policy associated with Lee Kwan Yew and his ruling Peoples Action Party, it is not a policy on which the PAP has a monopoly. A spokesman for the opposition Singapore Democratic Alliance, Edmund Ng, has said: For criminals, caning serves as a deterrent . I would not change a winning formula ( The New Paper . 13 April 2006). The other opposition party represented in Parliament, the Workers Party , while hostile to very long terms of imprisonment and mandatory sentences, also does not oppose JCP, at any rate for crimes of violence. In Malaysia, though, there is more opposition from academics, human rights activists and lawyers. In particular the countrys Bar Council, representing lawyers, unanimously passed a resolution in 2007 described whipping as cruel, inhumane and degrading, and called for its abolition, especially for illegal immigrants. However, there is no sign that the present government shares this view. In addition, in 2007 there was a proposal by the Women, Family and Community Development Ministry to abolish the judicial caning of juveniles in Malaysia. No such change in the law has yet been reported. SOME DIFFERENCES BETWEEN SINGAPORE AND MALAYSIA Terminology: In Singapore, the punishment is nowadays always described, both in legislation and in press reports, as caning. In Malaysia the term caning is often used informally, and the phrases strokes of the cane and strokes of the rotan are used interchangeably, but officially the correct term is whipping, following traditional British legislative terminology. Note: when Malaysian newspapers report that someone is to be whipped three times, it just means three strokes of the cane on a single occasion. In former British times, this would have meant three different caning sessions (in the 19th century, some UK legislation stipulated that an offender might be once, twice or thrice privately whipped, meaning an unspecified number of strokes on each of up to three separate occasions), but this usage has been lost sight of. Modus operandi: In Singapore and Brunei the culprit must bend over for his caning, with his feet together. In Malaysia he stands upright at the frame with his legs apart. Implements: The Malaysian cane is marginally smaller than the Singaporean one. This does not seem to make any discernible difference, if first-person accounts from the two jurisdictions are compared. Also, Malaysia uses a smaller cane for white-collar offenders -- those convicted of non-violent financial crimes such as embezzlement. There are no reports of any such distinction being made in Singapore. Juveniles: In Singapore, only the High Court may order the caning of boys under 16. In Malaysia local courts may do so. Islamic law: Malaysia has a parallel judicial system covering some sins that are offences only when committed by Moslems, who constitute about 60 of the population nationally. In theory some of these may attract caning sentences, though this happens rarely. When it does, the smaller cane is used and the mode of infliction is much less severe. Singapore, only about 15 of whose population are Moslems, has no such system. Main sources in addition to those mentioned in the text: Director of Prisons press conference, September 1974 (reported in numerous papers, e. g. Strokes of Tradition, The Australian . 19 September 1974, and Singapore Still Flogs Felons, unidentified US newspaper, 26 September 1974) Amnesty International Briefing on Singapore, January 1978 Singapore Lawmen Dont Spare the Rod Or Spoil the Criminal, Wall Street Journal . 6 July 1982 Amnesty International Bulletin, 1989 10 years on, and we still feel the pain, The New Paper . Singapore, 10 September 1991 Caning horror show deters the hooligans, Daily Telegraph . London, 23 April 1994 Prisons Department sets the facts straight on caning, Sunday Times . Singapore, 1 May 1994 An Appeal to Use the Rod Sparingly: A Dispassionate Analysis of the Use of Caning in Singapore, by Mark Lim Fung Chian, in Singapore Law Review . Vol. 15, 1994 The Caning of Michael Fay: The Inside Story by a Singaporean. by Gopal Baratham, KRP Publications, Singapore, 1994 Links to more legalofficial documents on Singapore JCP: Country files: Judicial CP in Singapore External links to other documents on aspects of Singapores JCP regime: Web links: Judicial CP Numerous reports of Singapore court sentences involving caning: Singapore - Judicial in The Archive for each year or group of years